Human Rights Law at Turkmenistan
Human Rights Law in Turkmenistan is formally established in the country’s Constitution and various national laws, but in practice, the human rights situation remains highly restricted. Turkmenistan is widely regarded as one of the most repressive countries in the world, with severe limitations on freedom of expression, assembly, religion, and movement.
1. Constitutional and Legal Framework
Constitution of Turkmenistan (most recently amended in 2016):
Provides for basic human rights and freedoms (e.g., equality before the law, right to education, healthcare, and work).
Claims to guarantee freedom of speech, conscience, religion, and peaceful assembly.
Declares the state secular and democratic.
However, these constitutional rights are not effectively implemented or protected in practice.
2. International Human Rights Obligations
Turkmenistan is a party to several international treaties, including:
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR)
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR)
Convention Against Torture (CAT)
Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW)
Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC)
Despite ratifying these treaties, compliance is extremely poor, and international bodies have frequently raised concerns.
3. Key Human Rights Issues
a. Freedom of Expression and Media
No independent media; all TV, radio, and newspapers are state-controlled.
Internet access is tightly censored; independent news websites are blocked.
Surveillance of internet use is widespread.
Speaking out against the government can lead to arrest, imprisonment, or enforced disappearance.
b. Freedom of Assembly and Association
Public gatherings require state approval, which is rarely granted for independent or critical voices.
No independent NGOs are allowed to operate freely; civil society is heavily suppressed.
Trade unions are controlled by the state.
c. Freedom of Religion
Only state-sanctioned religious groups are permitted to operate.
Unregistered religious activity is criminalized.
Surveillance and harassment of religious communities, especially Jehovah’s Witnesses and Muslims who practice independently, are common.
d. Torture and Arbitrary Detention
Torture is reportedly widespread in prisons and detention centers.
Prison conditions are extremely poor, with limited access to medical care and legal representation.
Many political prisoners are held incommunicado or have disappeared.
e. Political Rights
Turkmenistan is a one-party state in practice, despite nominal multiparty elections.
The president has sweeping powers, and elections are neither free nor fair.
There is no effective political opposition.
f. Freedom of Movement
Citizens face travel restrictions, both within the country and abroad.
The government maintains an informal "blacklist" of individuals banned from traveling abroad.
4. Women’s and Minority Rights
Gender inequality is significant, and violence against women is underreported and poorly addressed by authorities.
Ethnic minorities (e.g., Uzbeks, Russians) face discrimination in public sector employment and education.
LGBTQ+ rights are non-existent; same-sex relations between men are criminalized under Article 135 of the Criminal Code.
5. Legal System and Judiciary
Judiciary lacks independence and is subservient to the executive.
Trials are often closed and do not meet international standards for fairness.
Legal redress for human rights violations is nearly impossible.
6. International Criticism and Monitoring
UN Human Rights Committee, Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, and the U.S. State Department have consistently criticized Turkmenistan’s poor human rights record.
Access to independent observers is severely restricted.
The UN Working Group on Enforced or Involuntary Disappearances has highlighted numerous unresolved cases.
7. National Institutions
Turkmenistan has an Ombudsman for Human Rights (established in 2017), but the office has limited independence and impact.
Civil society and lawyers face tight restrictions, and victims of abuse have almost no domestic avenues for justice.
Summary
| Aspect | Legal Framework | Actual Practice |
|---|---|---|
| Freedom of Expression | Guaranteed in Constitution | Severely restricted |
| Freedom of Religion | Guaranteed | Heavily regulated and persecuted |
| Judicial Independence | Claimed | Subordinate to executive |
| Political Rights | Nominal multiparty system | Single-party control |
| Torture/Abuse | Prohibited by law | Systemic and widespread |
| Media and Internet | Claimed free press | State-controlled, censored internet |
Conclusion
While Turkmenistan’s legal framework formally guarantees many human rights, in reality, systemic repression and authoritarian rule render these rights largely meaningless. Genuine reform would require not only legislative changes but also a significant shift in political will and governance practices.
RELATED Blog
0 comments