Insolvency Law at Yemen
Insolvency law in Yemen is relatively underdeveloped and is influenced by a mix of civil law, Islamic (Sharia) law, and customary practices. Due to political instability, armed conflict, and a weak institutional framework, the legal system—including bankruptcy and insolvency procedures—is often inconsistently applied, and in many cases, functionally ineffective.
Here’s a detailed overview of insolvency law in Yemen:
1. Legal Framework
Yemen's insolvency system is primarily based on its Commercial Code (Law No. 32 of 1991).
Bankruptcy procedures are outlined in the Bankruptcy Section of this code.
The legal framework lacks modern features found in insolvency systems of more developed economies.
2. Types of Insolvency
Yemen’s Commercial Code recognizes two general categories:
Bankruptcy of individuals and merchants: Procedures are mainly for traders or business owners who fail to meet their financial obligations.
Corporate bankruptcy: Limited provisions exist for company liquidations, but there is no comprehensive corporate insolvency regime like Chapter 11 (U.S.) or administration (UK).
3. Bankruptcy Procedures
Under Yemeni law:
A debtor or creditor may petition the Commercial Court to declare bankruptcy.
If the court agrees, it appoints a trustee to manage the liquidation of the debtor’s assets.
Creditors must submit claims, and the trustee is responsible for asset distribution.
The law distinguishes between honest bankruptcy (due to bad luck) and fraudulent bankruptcy (due to negligence or deceit), with the latter potentially resulting in criminal penalties.
4. Judicial Involvement
Bankruptcy proceedings are heavily reliant on court intervention.
However, Yemen’s judicial system is fragile, particularly since the outbreak of the civil war in 2014. Many courts are nonfunctional or face serious resource and security constraints.
5. Creditor Rights and Asset Distribution
The code defines priority of claims, with secured creditors, employees, and government taxes generally taking precedence.
Unsecured creditors may receive little or no repayment.
Creditors have limited tools for asset tracing or recovery, especially in politically unstable areas.
6. Rehabilitation and Restructuring
Yemen's insolvency law is liquidation-focused. There is no effective mechanism for business restructuring or corporate rehabilitation, which makes it harder for viable businesses in temporary distress to recover.
There is no formal equivalent of debtor-in-possession financing or automatic stay provisions like in U.S. or EU systems.
7. Sharia Influence
Islamic principles influence bankruptcy indirectly, particularly in terms of:
Prohibitions on interest (riba), which complicate debt enforcement.
Ethical obligations of debt forgiveness and restructuring in hardship cases.
However, the commercial law is largely secular and codified.
8. Challenges and Limitations
Enforcement: Even if courts rule in favor of creditors, actual enforcement is difficult, especially amid ongoing conflict and weak governance.
Lack of Modern Infrastructure: Yemen does not have a credit registry or modern insolvency administrators.
Political Instability: The ongoing conflict deeply affects the functioning of the legal system, including insolvency procedures.
9. International Assessment
According to the World Bank's Doing Business reports (prior to discontinuation), Yemen ranked poorly in “Resolving Insolvency” due to:
Lack of reorganization procedures
Long delays
Low recovery rates
Lack of professional insolvency practitioners
Conclusion
Yemen’s insolvency law is outdated, liquidation-centric, and hampered by a weak judiciary and political instability. There is an urgent need for reform to provide for corporate restructuring, improve creditor protections, and enhance legal certainty. However, any meaningful change is unlikely without broader institutional and political stabilization.
RELATED Blog
0 comments