The legal status and powers of administrative authorities The Crown Ministers Civil service, including executive agencies Local authorities Regulatory agencies Other public authorities, e g the National Health Service
🔷 Legal Status and Powers of Administrative Authorities in the UK
1. 🏛️ The Crown
Legal Status:
The Crown represents the legal embodiment of executive authority.
Legally, the executive powers are vested in the Crown but are exercised by Ministers and civil servants on its behalf.
Powers:
Prerogative Powers: Residual powers of the Crown not overridden by statute (e.g., foreign affairs, defence).
Statutory Powers: Where Parliament delegates specific duties or responsibilities.
📌 Case Law:
🔹 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Fire Brigades Union [1995] 2 AC 513
Held that prerogative powers cannot override statute.
Home Secretary attempted to use prerogative powers to introduce a new compensation scheme without implementing a statutory one.
✅ Impact: Courts can review Crown’s actions when exercised through Ministers; rule of law prevails over executive discretion.
2. 👔 Ministers of the Crown
Legal Status:
Ministers are public officials appointed by the Crown and accountable to Parliament.
They exercise statutory powers and also instruct civil servants.
Powers:
Implement legislation.
Formulate and execute policy.
Make regulations under enabling Acts.
Issue guidance and directions.
📌 Case Law:
🔹 R v Secretary of State for Transport, ex parte Factortame (No. 2) [1991] 1 AC 603
Concerned the UK Merchant Shipping Act conflicting with EU law.
Court disapplied UK statute due to breach of EU obligations.
✅ Impact: Ministerial powers are not absolute and are subject to judicial oversight, especially when fundamental rights or legal obligations are affected.
3. 🏢 Civil Service (Including Executive Agencies)
Legal Status:
Civil servants are part of the executive branch, appointed under the royal prerogative, but functionally operate under Ministers.
Executive Agencies are semi-autonomous units carrying out government functions (e.g., DVLA, HMRC).
Powers:
Operational delivery of services.
Enforcing regulations.
Issuing licenses and permits.
Processing benefits, taxes, and pensions.
📌 Case Law:
🔹 Doody v Secretary of State for the Home Department [1994] 1 AC 531
Civil servants denied prisoners a right to reasons for parole denial.
✅ Impact: Even administrative decisions taken by civil servants under ministerial instructions must comply with natural justice, particularly when rights are affected.
4. 🏙️ Local Authorities
Legal Status:
Statutory corporations created by Parliament (e.g., under Local Government Acts).
They are independent legal persons, capable of suing and being sued.
Powers:
Local governance (planning, education, housing, social care).
Taxation (e.g., council tax).
Enforcing bylaws.
Providing local services.
📌 Case Law:
🔹 Roberts v Hopwood [1925] AC 578
A council increased wages for employees without proper financial consideration.
✅ Impact: Local authorities must act reasonably, in the public interest, and within their statutory framework.
5. 🧑⚖️ Regulatory Agencies
Legal Status:
Created by statute or delegated legislation.
May be independent or accountable to a Minister.
Examples: Ofcom, Ofwat, Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).
Powers:
Rule-making (quasi-legislative).
Licensing and monitoring.
Enforcement and sanctions.
Adjudication in regulated sectors.
📌 Case Law:
🔹 R (on the application of Bennett) v HM Coroner for Inner South London [2007] EWCA Civ 617
Questioned a regulator’s duty to investigate deaths in custody.
✅ Impact: Regulatory bodies can be subject to judicial review when failing to fulfill public obligations.
6. 🏥 Other Public Authorities (e.g., NHS Bodies)
Legal Status:
NHS bodies are established under the National Health Service Act 2006.
Operate as statutory public authorities with health service delivery responsibilities.
Powers:
Clinical commissioning.
Budgetary allocation.
Healthcare delivery and management.
Compliance with health policies and standards.
📌 Case Law:
🔹 R v Cambridge Health Authority, ex parte B [1995] 1 WLR 898
A young girl with leukemia was denied an experimental treatment by the NHS due to cost and uncertainty.
✅ Impact: Courts will defer to administrative resource-based decisions, but the reasoning must be lawful, rational, and proportionate.
⚖️ Summary Table
| Authority Type | Legal Status | Key Case | Key Principle Established |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crown | Sovereign authority; power through Ministers | Fire Brigades Union (1995) | Prerogative cannot override statute |
| Ministers | Constitutional office-holders | Factortame (1991) | Ministerial powers subject to legal limits |
| Civil Service | Executive actors under Ministers | Doody (1994) | Civil service decisions must follow natural justice |
| Local Authorities | Statutory bodies | Roberts v Hopwood (1925) | Must act reasonably and within statutory powers |
| Regulatory Agencies | Independent or Ministerial bodies | Bennett (2007) | Regulatory duty subject to judicial review |
| NHS/Public Authorities | Statutory service providers | Cambridge Health Authority (1995) | Health funding decisions must be rational and fair |
✅ Conclusion
In the UK, administrative authorities derive their powers from statutes, the Crown, or prerogative powers, but they are always subject to:
The rule of law
Judicial review
Principles of natural justice and proportionality
Courts have developed a strong body of case law to check misuse of administrative power, and while some bodies (like Ministers) enjoy discretion, that discretion is never unfettered.
RELATED Blog
0 comments