Find case law;
Finding Case Law
What is Case Law?
Case law refers to the collection of past judicial decisions written by courts and tribunals, which guide and influence future legal decisions. It forms a major part of common law systems like India’s.
Importance of Finding Case Law
To understand how courts interpret statutes and legal principles.
To apply established legal precedents to new facts.
To predict likely judicial outcomes.
To challenge or support arguments based on previous judgments.
How to Find Case Law?
Using Legal Databases:
Digital platforms like SCC Online, Manupatra, and official Supreme Court/High Court websites provide searchable access to case law.
Using Law Reports:
Published law reports (e.g., All India Reporter, Supreme Court Cases) compile judgments chronologically and by subject.
Using Citation and Headnotes:
Judgments are cited using party names, year, court, and page number. Headnotes summarize key points to help locate relevant decisions.
Using Keywords and Issues:
Search based on the legal issue, statute, or principle involved.
Checking Subsequent Citations:
Look for later cases that interpret or overrule earlier decisions.
Important Case Laws Demonstrating the Role of Finding and Using Case Law
1. Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973) AIR 1461
How Case Law Was Used:
The Supreme Court relied on multiple earlier cases to explore the extent of Parliament’s power to amend the Constitution, finally establishing the “basic structure” doctrine.
Significance:
This case shows how cumulative analysis of past precedents shapes landmark decisions.
2. Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978) AIR 597
How Case Law Was Used:
The Court revisited earlier narrow interpretations of personal liberty and broadened it by reading Articles 14, 19, and 21 together, departing from earlier precedents.
Significance:
Demonstrates how courts interpret existing case law dynamically to expand constitutional rights.
3. ADM Jabalpur v. Shivkant Shukla (1976) AIR 1207
How Case Law Was Used:
This controversial judgment, often called the “Habeas Corpus case,” was later heavily criticized and overruled in subsequent judgments, showing how case law evolves and is reinterpreted.
Significance:
Highlights the importance of reviewing and distinguishing precedents.
4. R.K. Garg v. Union of India (1981) AIR 1115
How Case Law Was Used:
This case involved constitutional validity of certain provisions of the Income Tax Act, where the Court used previous tax jurisprudence to uphold the law.
Significance:
Shows how case law is foundational in upholding or striking down laws based on prior interpretations.
5. S.P. Gupta v. Union of India (1981) AIR 149
How Case Law Was Used:
In the Judges’ transfer and appointment case, the Court analyzed previous judgments on separation of powers and judicial independence.
Significance:
Demonstrates how complex issues require synthesis of multiple case laws.
Summary
Finding case law involves identifying relevant precedents that interpret the law applicable to a dispute.
Courts analyze past decisions, apply, distinguish, or overrule them to resolve current issues.
Legal research tools and methods are essential for locating authoritative case law.
Landmark cases often rest on extensive citation and reinterpretation of previous decisions.
RELATED Blog
0 comments