Difference Between Possession and Ownership in Jurisprudence
Difference Between Possession and Ownership
1. Definition
| Aspect | Possession | Ownership |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Possession is the actual control or physical custody of a thing or property, regardless of legal title. | Ownership is the legal right or title to a property, giving the owner full control and rights over it. |
| Nature | Possession is a fact—an actual state of control. | Ownership is a legal right recognized by law. |
| Relationship | Possessor may or may not be the owner. | Owner may or may not be in possession. |
2. Characteristics
| Aspect | Possession | Ownership |
|---|---|---|
| Control | Physical control or holding of property. | Legal right to control and use property. |
| Transferability | Can transfer possession by delivery. | Ownership can be transferred by legal means. |
| Duration | Can be temporary or permanent. | Usually permanent until lawfully transferred. |
| Rights | Possessor has rights to use but limited; may protect possession. | Owner has full rights: use, sell, lease, or dispose of property. |
| Protection by Law | Possessor has some protection (e.g., against unlawful dispossession). | Ownership is fully protected and enforceable in law. |
3. Examples
A tenant possesses a house but does not own it.
A thief may possess stolen goods but does not own them.
The rightful owner may not be in possession if the property is leased or lost.
Important Case Law
1. Mulla vs. Mulla (1929)
The court explained the difference between possession and ownership, stating that possession is about actual control, whereas ownership is a right recognized by law.
It held that possession without ownership is possible and vice versa.
2. Halsbury’s Laws of England (General Principle)
Though a legal treatise, the principles stated here have been adopted by courts in distinguishing possession from ownership.
Possession is the fact of control, ownership is a legal relation.
3. K.K Verma vs. Union of India (1955)
The court held that possession is a condition precedent to ownership but they are conceptually distinct.
One can possess without owning, and ownership can exist without possession.
Summary of Differences
| Factor | Possession | Ownership |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Physical control | Legal right |
| Recognition | Fact | Right |
| Transfer | By delivery | By legal conveyance |
| Protection | Limited protection | Full legal protection |
| Relationship with property | May be temporary or unauthorized | Generally permanent and lawful |
Conclusion
Possession and ownership are distinct concepts in jurisprudence.
Possession focuses on the physical control over an object.
Ownership focuses on the legal entitlement to control, use, and dispose of the object.
Courts protect possession to a degree but ownership rights are paramount.
RELATED Blog
0 comments