Jurisprudence Law at Bosnia and Herzegovina
Jurisprudence and the Legal System in Bosnia and Herzegovina (BiH) are shaped by the country's complex political structure, stemming from its history and the consequences of the 1992-1995 Bosnian War. Bosnia and Herzegovina has a multi-layered legal framework that includes both national and entity-specific laws, influenced by international treaties and European Union (EU) law.
Here’s an overview of the legal system and jurisprudence in Bosnia and Herzegovina:
Legal System of Bosnia and Herzegovina
1. Constitutional Framework
The legal system of Bosnia and Herzegovina is established by the Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina, which was adopted in 1995 as part of the Dayton Agreement. The constitution reflects the country’s complex political structure as a result of the peace agreement that ended the Bosnian War. The country is divided into two entities:
Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina (FBiH) – Predominantly Bosniak and Croat.
Republika Srpska (RS) – Predominantly Serb.
Brčko District – A neutral area with its own administration.
These entities have their own parliaments and governments, and they create laws applicable within their territories, although Bosnia and Herzegovina also has state-level institutions for issues like foreign policy, defense, and international relations.
2. Sources of Law
Bosnia and Herzegovina’s legal system draws from a combination of sources, including:
Constitution: The Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina is the supreme law, but it is not a fully comprehensive document and leaves many issues to be regulated by the entities.
Laws: These are passed by the Parliament of Bosnia and Herzegovina, as well as the parliaments of the FBiH and RS.
International Treaties and Agreements: Bosnia and Herzegovina has signed numerous international agreements, especially as part of its aspirations for EU accession.
Judicial Decisions: The Constitutional Court of BiH and other courts’ decisions, especially in interpreting laws and resolving constitutional disputes, play a significant role in shaping jurisprudence.
3. Judicial Structure and Courts
The judicial system in Bosnia and Herzegovina is complex due to its political structure, with multiple courts operating at different levels:
Constitutional Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina: The highest court for constitutional issues. It resolves disputes about the constitutionality of laws and protects the constitutional rights of citizens.
State-level Courts:
Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina: Handles cases related to the state (e.g., national security, war crimes, state-level criminal offenses).
Prosecutor’s Office of Bosnia and Herzegovina: Responsible for prosecuting cases at the state level.
Entity Courts: Each entity has its own judiciary with courts of different levels, such as basic courts, district courts, and higher courts. These courts handle most criminal, civil, and administrative cases within their territories.
Supreme Court of the Federation of BiH and Supreme Court of Republika Srpska: The highest courts in their respective entities.
Brčko District Court: A separate judicial body for the Brčko District, which has its own administration and laws.
4. Role of the Constitutional Court
The Constitutional Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina plays a critical role in the judicial system. It is the highest court when it comes to issues of constitutionality, and it is also responsible for protecting human rights under the Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina. This court has nine judges, with equal representation from each constituent people (Bosniaks, Croats, and Serbs), plus three judges from other ethnic groups or international experts.
5. Legal Education and Profession
Legal education in Bosnia and Herzegovina is provided by universities, with the Faculty of Law at the University of Sarajevo, University of Banja Luka, and University of Mostar being among the leading institutions for legal studies. Graduates must pass bar exams to become practicing lawyers.
The Bar Associations in both entities, the Bar Association of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina and the Bar Association of Republika Srpska, regulate legal practice in their respective areas.
6. Legal Reforms and Challenges
The legal system in Bosnia and Herzegovina has undergone significant changes since the end of the war in the 1990s, with reforms aimed at strengthening rule of law, human rights protection, and judicial independence. These reforms have been driven, in part, by Bosnia and Herzegovina’s efforts to integrate into the European Union (EU) and comply with the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) standards.
However, the legal system still faces several challenges:
Political Influence on the Judiciary: Despite reforms, political influence remains a concern, especially in the context of the ethnically divided society. Political actors often try to exert influence over the judiciary in both entities.
Corruption: Corruption is a significant issue in Bosnia and Herzegovina, affecting not only the public sector but also the legal and judicial systems.
Slow Judicial Processes: Delays in court procedures are common, contributing to inefficiencies in the system.
7. Criminal Law and Human Rights
Bosnia and Herzegovina has made significant strides in addressing crimes committed during the Bosnian War through international courts, notably the War Crimes Chamber of the Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina. This court is responsible for prosecuting individuals accused of war crimes, genocide, and crimes against humanity, and it cooperates with the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY).
On human rights, Bosnia and Herzegovina is a party to several international conventions, including the European Convention on Human Rights, and its legal framework provides for the protection of fundamental rights, though implementation remains inconsistent.
8. EU Integration and Legal Harmonization
Bosnia and Herzegovina is an EU candidate country, and its legal system has been undergoing harmonization with EU standards in areas like:
Rule of Law: Strengthening the judiciary, combating corruption, and ensuring judicial independence.
Human Rights: Aligning domestic laws with European human rights standards.
Market Economy: Reforming commercial and property laws to facilitate economic growth and foreign investment.
Conclusion
Bosnia and Herzegovina’s legal system is highly complex, shaped by its post-war political framework and its ongoing efforts to integrate with European institutions. The country faces challenges related to judicial independence, corruption, and the efficiency of its legal system, but significant reforms have been implemented, particularly in relation to human rights, war crimes prosecution, and EU integration.
RELATED Blog
0 comments