Jurisprudence Law at Western Sahara
The legal system in Western Sahara is complex, as it is a disputed territory with a unique legal and political status. Western Sahara is claimed by both Morocco and the Polisario Front (a liberation movement that seeks independence for the region). This results in a hybrid legal system that draws from different sources depending on the area and the authorities governing it.
Here’s a breakdown of the legal system and jurisprudence in Western Sahara:
🔹 1. Legal and Political Status of Western Sahara
Western Sahara is recognized by the United Nations as a non-self-governing territory.
The region has been under Moroccan control since 1975 after Spain withdrew from its colonial rule. However, the Polisario Front declared the Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic (SADR), which is recognized by some countries and the African Union.
The region is still the subject of a long-standing dispute, and the United Nations continues to call for a referendum on self-determination.
🔹 2. Sources of Law
International Law
The status of Western Sahara is primarily governed by international law, especially United Nations Resolutions.
The UN Charter and international human rights law are often invoked by the Polisario Front and international organizations in advocating for the self-determination of the Sahrawi people.
Moroccan Law
In areas of Western Sahara controlled by Morocco, Moroccan law applies. This includes:
Moroccan Constitution: Morocco's constitution provides the framework for governance.
Moroccan Civil Law: Based on French civil law, Moroccan civil law governs issues like contracts, family law, and property law.
Sharia Law: While not fully codified, Islamic law plays a role, especially in family law matters, in Morocco-controlled areas.
Polisario Front-controlled Areas
The Polisario Front claims to govern the Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic (SADR), and its legal system is based on a combination of socialist principles and international law. It includes elements of Arab-Islamic law but has also adopted national laws aimed at advancing the goals of the Sahrawi people for independence and self-determination.
The Sahrawi Code: The legal framework in Polisario-controlled areas is influenced by socialist law and the legal traditions of the Arab world. However, it is still under development due to the ongoing conflict and limited governance.
🔹 3. Jurisprudence and Judicial Systems
Moroccan-Controlled Areas
Judiciary in Moroccan-controlled Western Sahara follows the Moroccan legal system, with courts for civil, criminal, and administrative matters.
Jurisprudence in Morocco is influenced by both Islamic law (Sharia) and French legal tradition.
The Court of Appeal in Laayoune, Western Sahara's largest city, operates under Moroccan law.
Human Rights Issues: The international community and human rights organizations often criticize Morocco’s handling of legal matters in the region, particularly issues of freedom of expression, treatment of Sahrawi activists, and human rights abuses.
Polisario Front-Controlled Areas
In the Polisario-controlled areas, Sahrawi law is more aspirational and influenced by a desire for self-determination and national identity.
The Sahrawi judicial system is still in development, with limited infrastructure and resources.
The judicial framework in these areas is often focused on individual rights, including the right to self-determination and freedom from Moroccan occupation.
International Law plays a critical role in the Polisario legal philosophy, especially principles of self-determination under the United Nations system.
🔹 4. Human Rights and International Law
Human rights concerns are a significant aspect of jurisprudence in Western Sahara. International human rights organizations often highlight issues such as:
Right to self-determination for the Sahrawi people.
Freedom of expression, freedom of assembly, and political freedoms in Moroccan-controlled territories.
The right to return for Sahrawi refugees.
International Court of Justice (ICJ) Advisory Opinion (1975): The ICJ ruled that there was no "sovereign" link between Morocco and Western Sahara, but it did recognize historical ties between Morocco and certain tribes in Western Sahara. The ruling emphasized the importance of a referendum for self-determination.
🔹 5. Current Legal Challenges and Future Prospects
The legal status of Western Sahara remains unresolved, with the UN still pushing for a referendum on self-determination that would allow the Sahrawi people to choose between independence or integration with Morocco.
The Sahrawi people continue to seek legal recognition through international mechanisms, and they use legal arguments in the African Union and other international forums to push for their cause.
In summary, jurisprudence in Western Sahara is heavily influenced by international law due to the ongoing territorial dispute. While Morocco applies Moroccan law in its controlled areas, the Polisario Front follows its own legal framework in the parts of the territory it governs, though both systems are subject to the broader dispute over the region's sovereignty.
RELATED Blog
0 comments