Jurisprudence Law at Malaysia
Jurisprudence in Malaysian Law refers to the theoretical and philosophical study of law in the context of Malaysia's unique legal system, which is a hybrid of common law, Islamic law (Syariah), and customary law.
Here's a breakdown of Jurisprudence as it applies in Malaysia:
🔹 1. Sources of Law in Malaysia
Malaysia’s legal system is influenced by multiple legal traditions:
Common Law (from British colonial rule)
Islamic Law (applicable mainly to Muslims in personal and family matters)
Customary Laws (Adat for Malays and native customs for Sabah and Sarawak)
Statutory Law (laws passed by Parliament and state legislatures)
Judicial Precedent (stare decisis from common law tradition)
🔹 2. Schools of Jurisprudence Influencing Malaysian Law
Several schools of jurisprudential thought shape Malaysia’s legal interpretation:
Natural Law Theory: Some Malaysian legal reasoning reflects moral reasoning, especially in constitutional rights cases.
Legal Positivism: Dominates the statutory interpretation, where law is seen as commands from the sovereign (Parliament).
Sociological Jurisprudence: Recognized in areas of family and Islamic law, acknowledging cultural and religious factors.
Islamic Jurisprudence (Fiqh): A significant source of law in Syariah courts, with influences from different Islamic schools (mainly Shafi'i).
🔹 3. Constitutional Supremacy
The Federal Constitution of Malaysia is the supreme law of the land (Article 4), and jurisprudential debates often revolve around:
Balancing Islamic law and secular law
Fundamental liberties (Part II of the Constitution)
Doctrine of separation of powers
Rule of law
🔹 4. Jurisprudential Issues in Practice
Key jurisprudential questions in Malaysia include:
To what extent should Islamic law influence civil law?
How should customary law be integrated with statutory law?
What is the role of judges in interpreting the Constitution — activism vs restraint?
Should Malaysia adopt a more pluralist jurisprudence to accommodate its multicultural society?
🔹 5. Case Law Illustrating Jurisprudential Issues
Some landmark cases:
Indira Gandhi v Pengarah Jabatan Agama Islam Perak (2018): Conflict between Islamic conversion laws and constitutional rights.
Lina Joy v Majlis Agama Islam (2007): Highlights tension between freedom of religion and Syariah law.
Semenyih Jaya Sdn Bhd v Pentadbir Tanah Daerah Hulu Langat (2017): Emphasized judicial independence.
🔹 6. Legal Education and Jurisprudence
Malaysian law faculties teach jurisprudence as a core subject, typically covering:
Theories of law (natural law, positivism, realism)
Islamic jurisprudence (Usul al-Fiqh)
Malaysian legal system and philosophy
Comparative jurisprudence (Western vs Islamic)
RELATED Blog
0 comments