Underwater Crimes And Maritime Security
๐ What Are Underwater Crimes?
Underwater crimes refer to illegal acts committed in or under territorial waters, including:
Piracy
Smuggling (arms, drugs, gold, etc.)
Human trafficking
Illegal fishing
Attacks on vessels/submarines
Destruction of underwater cables or pipelines
Terrorism at sea
Pollution or dumping of toxic substances
โ What is Maritime Security?
Maritime security refers to protecting territorial waters, Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZ), ports, coastal areas, sea lanes, and underwater infrastructure from criminal activities and threats to national security.
๐ฎ๐ณ INDIAN LEGAL FRAMEWORK FOR UNDERWATER CRIMES & MARITIME SECURITY
The Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) โ applicable to Indian citizens and crimes in Indian waters.
The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC)
The Territorial Waters, Continental Shelf, EEZ and Other Maritime Zones Act, 1976
The Suppression of Unlawful Acts Against Safety of Maritime Navigation and Fixed Platforms on Continental Shelf Act, 2002 (SUA Act)
The Indian Coast Guard Act, 1978
The Maritime Zones of India (Regulation of Fishing by Foreign Vessels) Act, 1981
International Conventions: UNCLOS, 1982; IMO conventions; SUA Convention
๐ JURISDICTION IN MARITIME CRIMES
Territorial Waters (up to 12 nautical miles): Full Indian sovereignty.
Contiguous Zone (12โ24 nm): Limited control for customs, immigration, and pollution.
EEZ (up to 200 nm): Rights for resources and environmental control.
High Seas: International waters โ subject to international law and Indian law for Indian flagged vessels or nationals.
๐ IMPORTANT CASE LAWS ON UNDERWATER CRIMES & MARITIME SECURITY
1. MV Elizabeth Case (1992) โ Supreme Court of India
Facts:
MV Elizabeth, a foreign ship, collided with an Indian fishing boat. Dispute arose over jurisdiction.
Judgment:
Supreme Court held that Indian admiralty jurisdiction extends to foreign ships in Indian waters. Indian courts can entertain civil or criminal matters related to maritime incidents.
Significance:
Established that Indian courts have broad admiralty jurisdiction, especially when the incident impacts Indian waters or citizens.
2. Republic of Italy v. Union of India (Enrica Lexie Case), 2013
Facts:
Two Italian marines aboard the ship "Enrica Lexie" shot and killed two Indian fishermen off the coast of Kerala, claiming they mistook them for pirates.
Issues:
Whether India had jurisdiction, since the shooting occurred in Indiaโs Contiguous Zone.
Judgment:
Supreme Court held that India had jurisdiction under its maritime laws and sovereign rights under international law (UNCLOS) since the incident affected Indian citizens and security.
Significance:
Landmark case for maritime criminal jurisdiction and use of force in international waters.
3. Captain Subhash Kumar v. Union of India (1991)
Facts:
Captain of a foreign vessel was arrested for illegal oil discharge in Indian waters causing marine pollution.
Judgment:
Court held that Indian authorities have the power to detain foreign ships and prosecute individuals violating environmental and maritime laws in Indian territorial and EEZ waters.
Significance:
Confirmed India's authority in environmental and ecological protection of its maritime zones.
4. State v. Mohamed Ismail (Madras High Court, 1993)
Facts:
Case involving smuggling of gold and weapons through underwater diving and boats near the Rameswaram coast.
Judgment:
Court observed that crimes committed using underwater methods or in shallow waters are within Indian criminal jurisdiction and a serious threat to national security.
Significance:
Established precedent that underwater smuggling is a national security concern, not just a customs violation.
5. MV Alondra Rainbow Case (2003)
Facts:
A Japanese cargo ship was hijacked by pirates, who were later caught by the Indian Coast Guard.
Judgment:
Indian courts tried the pirates under IPC and maritime laws. The Bombay High Court ruled that India has jurisdiction over piracy in high seas if pirates are apprehended by Indian authorities.
Significance:
Crucial for defining piracy jurisdiction and Indiaโs commitment to international maritime enforcement.
6. Abdul Rehman Antulay v. R.S. Nayak, AIR 1988 SC 1531
Facts:
Although not directly a maritime case, this case clarified how criminal jurisdiction can extend extraterritorially when crimes affect Indian interests.
Judgment:
The court ruled that extra-territorial crimes can be tried in India if there's sufficient nexus.
Significance:
Supports jurisdiction over underwater crimes committed beyond territorial waters if Indian interests are affected.
7. Gujarat vs. Union of India (2004) โ Case on Marine Fishing Disputes
Facts:
Dispute between Gujarat and Centre over arrest of Pakistani fishermen within EEZ.
Judgment:
Supreme Court held that India has jurisdiction over EEZ and can prosecute foreign nationals under Indian laws for illegal entry or fishing.
Significance:
Strengthened sovereign control over EEZ and underwater resources.
๐ SUMMARY TABLE OF CASES
| Case | Issue | Legal Principle Established |
|---|---|---|
| MV Elizabeth Case (1992) | Admiralty jurisdiction | Indian courts can try foreign ships for civil/criminal matters |
| Enrica Lexie Case (2013) | Marines shot Indian fishermen | India has jurisdiction in Contiguous Zone under UNCLOS |
| Captain Subhash Kumar (1991) | Marine pollution | India can prosecute foreign ships for environmental crimes |
| State v. Mohamed Ismail | Underwater smuggling | Underwater crimes = national security threats |
| MV Alondra Rainbow (2003) | Piracy on high seas | India can try piracy cases under international and national law |
| Abdul Rehman Antulay (1988) | Extra-territorial crime | India can try crimes affecting Indian interests abroad |
| Gujarat v. Union of India | Arrest of foreign fishermen | India can enforce laws in EEZ and territorial waters |
โ๏ธ KEY TAKEAWAYS
India has extensive jurisdiction in territorial waters and limited but enforceable rights in the Contiguous Zone and EEZ.
Underwater crimes are prosecuted under IPC, SUA Act, and environmental laws depending on the nature of the offence.
Maritime security includes the protection of underwater infrastructure, detection of smuggling, piracy control, and environmental protection.
International cooperation is crucial in dealing with high seas piracy and underwater crimes that cross jurisdictions.
RELATED Blog
0 comments