Sedition and Freedom of Speech, Journey from Cognizance to Framing of Charges
Sedition and Freedom of Speech: Journey from Cognizance to Framing of Charges
1. Sedition: Meaning and Legal Provision
Definition: Sedition refers to conduct or speech that incites people to rebel against the authority of the state or government.
Legal Provision in India:
Section 124A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) defines sedition. It criminalizes any words, signs, or visible representations that incite hatred, contempt, or disaffection towards the government established by law.
2. Freedom of Speech vs Sedition
Constitutional Guarantee:
Article 19(1)(a) of the Indian Constitution guarantees freedom of speech and expression to all citizens.
Reasonable Restrictions:
Under Article 19(2), the state can impose reasonable restrictions on this freedom in the interests of:
Sovereignty and integrity of India,
Security of the state,
Public order,
Decency or morality, etc.
Balancing Act:
Sedition law aims to protect the state from incitement to violence or rebellion, but it must not be used to stifle legitimate dissent or criticism.
Judicial Interpretation:
The Supreme Court in cases like Kedar Nath Singh v. State of Bihar (1962) clarified that only speech or acts involving incitement to violence or public disorder amount to sedition. Mere criticism or expression of discontent is not sedition.
3. Journey from Cognizance to Framing of Charges in Sedition Cases
Step 1: Cognizance of Offence
Definition: Cognizance means the court’s recognition that a case exists and that judicial proceedings can begin.
Under Section 190(1)(a) of CrPC, a magistrate can take cognizance:
On complaint,
On police report,
Or upon own knowledge.
In sedition cases, cognizance generally happens upon receiving a police report or complaint.
Step 2: Investigation
After cognizance, the police investigate the allegations.
This includes collecting evidence, recording statements, and examining the accused.
Sedition being a non-bailable and cognizable offence, the police have authority to arrest and start investigation without magistrate’s prior permission.
Step 3: Filing of Charge Sheet
Post-investigation, the police file a charge sheet under Section 173 CrPC.
The charge sheet contains:
Details of the investigation,
Evidence,
Names of witnesses,
Relevant documents.
If evidence is insufficient, a final report of closure may be filed.
Step 4: Commencement of Trial
Upon receiving the charge sheet, the court takes cognizance for trial purposes.
The accused is produced in court if not already present.
Step 5: Framing of Charges
The magistrate reads the charges against the accused under Section 228 CrPC.
Charges specify the offence (here, sedition under Section 124A IPC).
The accused is asked to plead guilty or not guilty.
If the accused pleads not guilty, trial proceeds.
4. Important Judicial Safeguards
Reasonable Limits: Speech must incite violence or public disorder to constitute sedition.
Proportionality: Arrest and prosecution should not be used to suppress peaceful dissent.
Bail Considerations: Sedition being serious, bail may be denied, but courts have discretion based on facts.
5. Contemporary Context
Sedition law has often been criticized for misuse against journalists, activists, and dissenters.
Calls for its repeal or amendment have grown to prevent infringement on free speech.
Governments and courts are urged to ensure the law is used sparingly and judiciously.
Summary Table
| Stage | Description |
|---|---|
| Cognizance | Court recognizes offence; can start proceedings |
| Investigation | Police collect evidence and interrogate accused |
| Charge Sheet Filing | Police submit report with evidence to court |
| Trial Commencement | Court takes cognizance for trial; accused appears |
| Framing of Charges | Court formally charges accused under sedition law |
Do write to us if you need any further assistance.
RELATED Blog
0 comments