West UP Having Its Own Bench Of High Court Will Help Undertrials And Overall Criminal Justice System Will Stand To...
How having a separate High Court bench for West Uttar Pradesh (West UP) would benefit undertrials and strengthen the overall criminal justice system,
West UP Having Its Own Bench of High Court: Impact on Undertrials and Criminal Justice System
I. Background
Uttar Pradesh is India’s most populous state, with a large volume of criminal cases and overcrowded prisons. West UP, comprising several districts, currently depends mainly on the Allahabad High Court, which is physically located far from many districts in West UP.
II. Key Issues Faced by Undertrials in West UP
Delayed Justice:
Cases are often delayed due to the huge backlog in courts.
Undertrials spend long periods in custody awaiting trial.
Long pendency impacts speedy trial rights under Article 21 of the Constitution.
Distance and Accessibility:
Travel to Allahabad High Court (located in eastern UP) is difficult and costly.
Many undertrials and their lawyers face logistical and financial hardships.
Limited access to legal aid and timely appeals.
Overburdened Courts:
Allahabad High Court handles cases from the entire state, causing overcrowding and administrative inefficiency.
Delay in hearings and judgments.
III. How a Dedicated West UP Bench Would Help
1. Speedier Disposal of Cases
A local bench would reduce the burden on Allahabad High Court.
Quicker hearing of bail applications, appeals, and revisions.
Early hearing helps undertrials get timely bail or acquittal.
2. Improved Access to Justice
Proximity to courts means undertrials, families, and lawyers can participate more effectively.
Reduced travel time and expenses.
Easier for legal aid providers and public prosecutors to coordinate.
3. Decongestion of Prisons
Timely trials reduce unnecessary incarceration.
Reduction in undertrial population aligns with the Supreme Court’s directives on prison reforms.
4. Strengthening the Rule of Law
Quicker judicial intervention upholds fundamental rights.
Local bench better understands regional socio-economic realities, which aids in fairer adjudication.
IV. Supporting Legal Principles & Case Laws
1. Right to Speedy Trial
Hussainara Khatoon v. State of Bihar (1979) 3 SCC 532
The Supreme Court recognized speedy trial as an essential part of the right to life and liberty under Article 21.
Observed the plight of undertrials languishing in jail for years without trial.
Directed steps to ensure speedy disposal and release of undertrials.
2. Access to Justice and Fair Trial
Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978) 1 SCC 248
Emphasized that any procedure depriving personal liberty must be “just, fair, and reasonable.”
Highlights the importance of accessibility and fairness in judicial processes.
3. Relief for Undertrials by Court Expansion
In Sheela Barse v. Union of India (1986) 3 SCC 596, the court called for urgent prison reforms including reduction in undertrial population.
The courts have recognized the link between infrastructure, judicial capacity, and prisoners' rights.
4. Decentralization for Judicial Efficiency
State of Karnataka v. Union of India (1978) 4 SCC 608
Affirmed the need for decentralization and local accessibility in judicial systems to uphold justice.
The principle of judicial accessibility also supports the demand for regional benches to reduce strain on central benches.
V. Wider Criminal Justice System Benefits
Reduced pendency improves the overall quality of criminal justice.
Enables better coordination between police, prosecution, defense, and judiciary.
Encourages more effective legal aid and rehabilitation programs.
Promotes public confidence in the justice system.
Aligns with National Judicial Policy aimed at timely justice.
VI. Conclusion
Establishing a dedicated High Court bench for West UP will:
Directly benefit undertrial prisoners by providing speedier access to justice,
Reduce the burden on the Allahabad High Court,
Improve prison conditions by preventing prolonged pre-trial detention,
And strengthen the overall criminal justice delivery system in Uttar Pradesh.
RELATED Blog
0 comments