Crimes Against Humanity During Conflict Periods
Definition
Crimes against humanity are certain acts deliberately committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack directed against any civilian population, with knowledge of the attack. These acts can occur during peace or conflict but are particularly associated with war and conflict settings.
Core Acts Constituting Crimes Against Humanity
Under international law (Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, customary international law), these acts include:
Murder
Extermination
Enslavement
Deportation or forcible transfer of population
Imprisonment or other severe deprivation of physical liberty
Torture
Rape and other forms of sexual violence
Persecution against any identifiable group
Enforced disappearance of persons
Apartheid
Other inhumane acts causing great suffering or serious injury
Elements of Crimes Against Humanity
Must be part of a widespread or systematic attack.
Directed against a civilian population.
Carried out with knowledge of the attack.
Requires state or organizational policy, or tacit approval.
Case Studies
Case 1: The Darulaman Massacres, Afghanistan (1990s)
Context: During the civil war following the Soviet withdrawal, various factions, including government forces and militias, committed widespread atrocities against civilians in Kabul’s Darulaman area.
Crimes: Summary executions, mass killings, and torture were reported.
Legal Relevance: These acts constitute murder and torture as crimes against humanity when systematic.
Outcome: No formal accountability was achieved, illustrating challenges in prosecuting crimes in internal conflicts.
Significance: Example of internal conflict atrocities meeting the threshold for crimes against humanity.
Case 2: Forced Displacement of Hazara Population in Bamyan Province (2001-2004)
Incident: Taliban and allied militias forcibly displaced thousands of Hazara civilians based on ethnic and religious identity.
Crimes: Persecution, forced displacement, and destruction of property.
Legal Framework: Persecution on ethnic grounds is a recognized crime against humanity.
Aftermath: Limited justice; displacement led to significant humanitarian crises.
Significance: Highlights ethnic targeting as crimes against humanity.
Case 3: Mass Sexual Violence During the Kosovo Conflict (1998-1999)
Background: Widespread rape and sexual slavery committed by Serbian forces against Kosovar Albanians.
Crimes: Systematic sexual violence as part of ethnic cleansing.
Legal Proceedings: Prosecuted at the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY), setting important precedents.
Outcome: High-ranking officials were convicted for crimes against humanity.
Significance: Reinforced international recognition of sexual violence as crimes against humanity.
Case 4: Enforced Disappearances in Sri Lanka (2006-2009)
Details: Thousands of Tamils disappeared during the final phase of the civil war.
Crimes: Enforced disappearance, extrajudicial killings.
Legal Status: Classified as crimes against humanity due to systematic nature.
Judicial Action: Calls for international investigation continue; domestic accountability has been limited.
Significance: Shows enforced disappearance as a key crime against humanity.
Case 5: The Rohingya Crisis in Myanmar (2017)
Context: Military-led operations targeted Rohingya Muslims involving mass killings, rapes, and forced displacement.
Crimes: Murder, rape, persecution, and forced transfer.
International Action: ICC authorized investigation into crimes against humanity.
Significance: A contemporary example of crimes against humanity during conflict leading to international legal action.
Afghan Law and Crimes Against Humanity
Afghanistan’s Penal Code (2017) incorporates provisions criminalizing:
Crimes against humanity (Article 423).
Torture and extrajudicial killings.
Enforced disappearance.
However, enforcement has been limited due to ongoing conflict, weak institutions, and political instability.
Summary
Crimes against humanity involve systematic attacks on civilian populations, including murder, torture, rape, and persecution.
These crimes often occur during conflicts but can also happen in peacetime.
Legal accountability requires demonstrating the systematic or widespread nature of the attacks and the involvement or acquiescence of authorities.
International tribunals have been key in prosecuting these crimes.
Many conflict zones, including Afghanistan, face serious challenges in addressing and prosecuting crimes against humanity.
RELATED Blog
0 comments