Document Fraud Immigration-Related Cases
1. United States v. Oscar Ramirez (2015)
Facts:
Oscar Ramirez, a non-citizen, was arrested for using a fake permanent resident card (green card) and a forged Social Security number to gain employment at a manufacturing plant in Texas.
Legal Issues:
Use of a fraudulent immigration document under 18 U.S.C. § 1546.
Aggravated identity theft (using someone else’s Social Security number).
Outcome:
Ramirez was convicted of both counts and sentenced to 18 months in prison followed by removal proceedings.
Significance:
Emphasizes that using fake documents, even just for work, carries federal criminal consequences.
Identity theft can significantly increase sentencing.
2. United States v. Maria Gonzalez (2017)
Facts:
Maria Gonzalez operated a small document mill in California, producing counterfeit green cards and employment authorization documents (EADs) for undocumented immigrants.
Legal Issues:
Manufacturing false immigration documents.
Conspiracy to commit immigration fraud.
Use of false documents under 18 U.S.C. §§ 371 and 1546.
Outcome:
Gonzalez was convicted and sentenced to 5 years in federal prison. Dozens of her clients were also referred to immigration court.
Significance:
Shows how document mills are aggressively prosecuted.
Highlights conspiracy charges and how even non-government employees can face immigration-related charges.
3. United States v. Ali Reza (2019)
Facts:
Ali Reza submitted fake asylum affidavits and forged supporting documents to USCIS on behalf of clients, including fabricated police reports from foreign countries.
Legal Issues:
Immigration application fraud.
False statements in immigration documents (18 U.S.C. § 1001).
Fraud in asylum proceedings.
Outcome:
Reza was convicted on multiple counts and sentenced to 7 years in prison.
Significance:
Illustrates that even legal professionals (or those posing as them) can be prosecuted.
Fraudulent asylum claims can result in both criminal and immigration consequences.
4. United States v. Daniel Okoye (2014)
Facts:
Okoye, a Nigerian national, entered the U.S. with a fraudulently obtained student visa, using falsified academic records and a forged I-20 form.
Legal Issues:
Visa fraud under 18 U.S.C. § 1546.
Use of fraudulent documents to gain immigration benefits.
Outcome:
Okoye was convicted and sentenced to 30 months in prison followed by deportation.
Significance:
Demonstrates that visa fraud based on academic fraud is still criminally punishable.
I-20 document fraud is a common issue with student visa misuse.
5. United States v. Juan Pablo Martinez (2020)
Facts:
Martinez used a false U.S. birth certificate to obtain a U.S. passport and tried to sponsor family members based on that false identity.
Legal Issues:
Passport fraud under 18 U.S.C. § 1542.
False claim to U.S. citizenship (18 U.S.C. § 911).
Immigration benefit fraud.
Outcome:
Martinez was sentenced to 4 years in federal prison and his naturalization petition was denied permanently.
Significance:
False claims to U.S. citizenship are extremely serious.
Immigration fraud involving benefit stacking (multiple frauds) results in harsh penalties.
6. United States v. Lilia Torres (2022)
Facts:
Torres, a notario (non-lawyer immigration advisor), submitted fake marriage certificates and joint financial records to USCIS to help clients obtain green cards through fraudulent marriages.
Legal Issues:
Immigration benefit fraud under 8 U.S.C. § 1325(c).
Submitting fraudulent documents to a federal agency.
Outcome:
Torres was convicted and sentenced to 6 years in prison, and over 40 of her clients were placed in removal proceedings.
Significance:
Marriage fraud cases are often tied to document fraud.
“Notario” fraud is a major issue in immigrant communities, and prosecutors are increasingly cracking down.
Summary Table
| Case | Type of Fraud | Outcome | Legal Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ramirez (2015) | Fake green card & SSN | 18 months + removal | Shows seriousness of ID & employment fraud |
| Gonzalez (2017) | Running document mill | 5 years | Conspiracy & manufacturing fake docs |
| Reza (2019) | False asylum documents | 7 years | Asylum fraud & false federal statements |
| Okoye (2014) | Fake student visa paperwork | 30 months + deportation | Education-based visa fraud |
| Martinez (2020) | False citizenship & passport | 4 years | Citizenship fraud severely punished |
| Torres (2022) | Fake marriage documents | 6 years | Crackdown on notario and marriage fraud |
Key Legal Takeaways:
Document fraud in immigration is charged under several statutes:
18 U.S.C. § 1546 (fraud & misuse of visas)
18 U.S.C. § 1001 (false statements)
18 U.S.C. § 1542 (passport fraud)
8 U.S.C. § 1325(c) (immigration benefit fraud)
Both individual applicants and service providers (like notarios or fake attorneys) can be criminally liable.
Penalties are severe, especially when:
The fraud involves false claims to U.S. citizenship.
Multiple forged documents are used.
The fraud results in illegal benefits (like green cards or passports).
RELATED Blog
0 comments