Chit Fund Scams And Ponzi Schemes
What is a Chit Fund?
A Chit Fund is a type of rotating savings and credit system popular in India and some other countries. It involves a group of people contributing a fixed amount regularly, and one member receives the collected amount through an auction or lottery each cycle.
Legitimate chit funds are regulated under the Chit Funds Act, 1982.
These funds operate legally when registered and follow strict guidelines.
What is a Chit Fund Scam?
When operators of chit funds defraud investors by either:
Misappropriating the money collected,
Running unregistered chit funds, or
Using collected money for personal gains without repaying investors,
it becomes a chit fund scam.
What is a Ponzi Scheme?
A Ponzi scheme is a fraudulent investment operation where returns to earlier investors are paid from the capital of new investors, not from profits earned. This model is unsustainable and eventually collapses when new investments stop.
Differences:
Chit Fund: Can be legal if registered and regulated.
Ponzi Scheme: Always illegal, fraudulent by nature.
Case Studies of Chit Fund Scams and Ponzi Schemes
1. Sahara India Pariwar Case (Sahara Scam)
Background: Sahara India Real Estate Corporation Ltd and Sahara Housing Investment Corporation Ltd collected over ₹24,000 crore from millions of investors via optionally fully convertible debentures (OFCDs).
Scam Nature: Sahara claimed these were investment schemes exempt from SEBI (Securities and Exchange Board of India) regulations. SEBI alleged that these were unregulated collective investment schemes akin to Ponzi schemes.
Legal Proceedings:
In 2012, SEBI ordered Sahara to refund money to investors with 15% interest.
Sahara contested, but the Supreme Court of India upheld SEBI's order in 2014.
Sahara was asked to refund over ₹24,000 crore, and the case included freezing assets.
Outcome: Sahara had to refund the investors under Supreme Court supervision, marking a landmark case in controlling large-scale financial scams.
2. Pearl Agrotech Chit Fund Scam (Punjab and Haryana)
Background: Pearl Agrotech, an unregistered chit fund company, collected money from thousands of investors promising high returns.
Scam Nature: The company defaulted on payments, causing huge losses. It was found operating without registration and regulatory approval.
Legal Proceedings:
The State government raided the company, arrested promoters.
Multiple FIRs were filed for cheating and criminal breach of trust.
Outcome: The promoters were prosecuted under the Chit Funds Act and Indian Penal Code (IPC) sections related to fraud and criminal breach of trust.
3. Speak Asia Online Ponzi Scheme
Background: Speak Asia was an online survey-based company promising high returns through membership fees.
Scam Nature: It was declared a Ponzi scheme by SEBI in 2011 because the promised returns were paid from the fees collected from new members.
Legal Proceedings:
SEBI issued cease and desist orders.
The promoters were arrested.
Outcome: SEBI asked Speak Asia to refund investors, marking a clear instance of a fraudulent Ponzi scheme under Indian securities law.
4. Saradha Group Financial Scandal (West Bengal)
Background: Saradha Group was a conglomerate running collective investment schemes primarily in Eastern India.
Scam Nature: It raised over ₹2000 crore from millions of small investors through chit fund-like schemes but failed to repay them.
Legal Proceedings:
The West Bengal government set up a Special Investigation Team (SIT).
The Supreme Court directed the central and state governments to protect investors.
Outcome: Several arrests were made, and the promoters faced charges under IPC sections 420 (cheating), 406 (criminal breach of trust) and Chit Funds Act. The government also created a fund to repay investors.
5. Gold Quest Group Ponzi Scam
Background: Gold Quest was an unregistered collective investment scheme operating in Kerala, promising high returns on gold investments.
Scam Nature: It collected thousands of crores from the public with no real investment, paying returns from new investments.
Legal Proceedings:
Kerala police and SEBI conducted investigations.
The promoters were arrested under IPC and Chit Funds Act.
Outcome: The scheme collapsed, and legal proceedings are ongoing with efforts to recover money for investors.
Legal Framework Involved
Chit Funds Act, 1982: Governs chit funds, requires registration, and defines penalties for fraud.
Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 (SEBI Act): Regulates collective investment schemes and ponzi schemes.
Indian Penal Code (IPC): Sections like 420 (cheating), 406 (criminal breach of trust), 120B (criminal conspiracy) are used in prosecution.
Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA): Sometimes invoked to freeze and confiscate assets.
Summary
Chit fund scams happen when chit fund companies misuse public money or operate illegally.
Ponzi schemes are inherently fraudulent and rely on new investor funds to pay old investors.
Enforcement agencies like SEBI, State Governments, and Courts have been active in cracking down on these scams.
Landmark cases like Sahara and Saradha have brought legal clarity and enforcement to protect investors.
RELATED Blog
0 comments