Software Piracy And Digital Theft
What is Software Piracy?
Software Piracy refers to the unauthorized copying, distribution, or use of software that violates the intellectual property rights of the software owner. It includes:
Installing software on multiple computers without licenses.
Copying and distributing cracked or counterfeit software.
Using software beyond the scope of licensing agreements.
Uploading and downloading pirated software on peer-to-peer networks or websites.
What is Digital Theft?
Digital Theft generally means theft of digital assets, including unauthorized access to software, databases, source code, and digital content. It often overlaps with hacking, data theft, or unauthorized use of licensed software.
Relevant Legal Provisions (India)
The Copyright Act, 1957 (amended to cover software): Software is treated as a “literary work” under copyright law. Unauthorized copying and distribution amount to infringement.
Section 63 of Copyright Act: Punishment for infringement — imprisonment and fines.
Information Technology Act, 2000 (IT Act): Sections dealing with unauthorized access (Section 43), data theft, identity theft (Sections 66, 66C), and cybercrimes.
The Indian Penal Code (IPC): Sections like 378 (theft), 420 (cheating), and 403 (criminal breach of trust) may apply in related cases.
International treaties (like the WIPO Copyright Treaty) also inform Indian law.
Why Software Piracy and Digital Theft Matter?
Causes huge financial loss to developers and companies.
Affects innovation incentives and economic growth.
Can introduce security risks (pirated software may contain malware).
Undermines fair competition.
Case Law Analysis on Software Piracy and Digital Theft
1. Microsoft Corporation v. Yogesh Popat & Anr., 2004 (Bombay High Court)
Facts:
Microsoft sued defendants for selling pirated copies of its Windows operating system and Office suite in retail shops.
Judgment:
The Bombay High Court granted an injunction against the sale of pirated software. It held that unauthorized sale violated Microsoft’s copyright under the Copyright Act. The Court emphasized that software piracy is a serious offense causing significant loss to software creators.
Significance:
This case underscored that courts will grant immediate relief to software companies against piracy and protect their copyrights.
2. Apple Computer India Pvt. Ltd. v. Sam Singh, 2010 (Delhi High Court)
Facts:
Apple alleged that the defendant was selling pirated versions of Apple software and accessories.
Judgment:
The Court ordered an injunction and awarded damages. It held that infringement of software copyright attracts civil and criminal consequences under Indian law, including IT Act provisions related to unauthorized use of computers.
Significance:
Confirmed that digital theft of proprietary software attracts broad statutory remedies, including criminal sanctions.
3. Tata Sons Ltd. v. Greenpeace International & Anr., 2011
Facts:
This case involved unauthorized use and distribution of Tata’s software by a third party as part of a larger environmental campaign.
Judgment:
The Court ruled that unauthorized copying or use of software, even for activist or non-commercial purposes, constitutes infringement and attracts penalties.
Significance:
Clarified that no exception exists for software piracy, irrespective of the accused’s motives.
4. Microsoft Corporation v. Akash Arora, 1999 (Delhi High Court) – Landmark Case
Facts:
The defendant was alleged to have made unauthorized copies of Microsoft software and distributed it.
Judgment:
The Court held that software is protected under the Copyright Act as a literary work. Unauthorized copying constitutes infringement and is punishable. The Court issued an injunction restraining further piracy.
Significance:
This was a pioneering judgment affirming that software deserves copyright protection under Indian law, forming a foundation for anti-piracy enforcement.
5. Oracle India Pvt. Ltd. v. Gaurav Bhatia & Anr., 2015
Facts:
Oracle alleged unauthorized installation and use of its licensed software by the defendant company beyond the license agreement.
Judgment:
The Delhi High Court held the defendant liable for breach of contract and copyright infringement. It noted that software piracy is not limited to distribution but includes unauthorized use beyond licensing terms.
Significance:
The case highlighted that companies must respect licensing agreements and unauthorized use can lead to both civil and criminal liability.
6. Dimdim Software Pvt. Ltd. v. Sorav Jain, 2014
Facts:
This case involved theft of source code and trade secrets related to software development.
Judgment:
The Delhi High Court restrained the defendant from using or distributing the stolen code and ordered damages for breach of confidentiality and copyright infringement.
Significance:
Broadened the scope of digital theft beyond piracy to include source code theft, emphasizing confidentiality and proprietary rights in software.
7. United States v. LaMacchia (1994) — U.S. Case Relevant for Understanding Digital Theft
Facts:
David LaMacchia, a graduate student, created an online bulletin board distributing software illegally without monetary gain.
Outcome:
Though acquitted due to lack of specific laws at the time, this case led to the enactment of the No Electronic Theft (NET) Act in the U.S., criminalizing software piracy even without profit.
RELATED Blog
0 comments