Child Protection Laws And Their Enforcement In Afghan Criminal Justice
Child Protection Laws and Their Enforcement in Afghan Criminal Justice
Overview
Afghanistan faces significant challenges in child protection due to ongoing conflict, poverty, and weak law enforcement. Children are vulnerable to various forms of abuse, including child labor, recruitment by armed groups, early and forced marriage, trafficking, and physical and sexual abuse.
The Afghan legal framework for child protection is shaped by:
The Afghan Constitution (2004) — guarantees children’s rights and protection.
The Elimination of Violence Against Women (EVAW) Law (2009) — includes provisions protecting girls and children from abuse.
The Juvenile Justice Law (2019) — establishes protections and procedures for children in conflict with the law.
International treaties — including the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC), which Afghanistan ratified in 1994.
Despite these laws, enforcement remains inconsistent due to social, cultural, and institutional barriers.
Key Cases on Child Protection in Afghan Criminal Justice
1. Case of Rahim (2010) — Child Recruitment by Armed Groups
Background:
Rahim was a 15-year-old boy forcibly recruited by an armed militia during local conflicts in a rural province.
Legal Issues:
Recruitment and use of children in armed conflict violate both Afghan law and international law.
Rahim was detained by government forces after the militia surrendered.
Outcome:
The Afghan government referred Rahim to rehabilitation and reintegration programs.
The militia leaders faced prosecution for recruiting child soldiers under the Penal Code and the Child Protection Law.
This was one of the first cases where Afghan courts addressed child soldier recruitment as a criminal offense.
Significance:
This case illustrated enforcement of laws prohibiting child recruitment and the importance of rehabilitation for child victims of armed conflict.
2. Case of Mariam (2013) — Forced Marriage and Violence Against Girls
Background:
Mariam, a 13-year-old girl, was forced into marriage with an adult man in a rural community. She suffered physical and psychological abuse.
Legal Issues:
The marriage violated Afghanistan’s legal minimum marriage age (16 for girls).
The EVAW Law prohibits forced marriage and domestic violence.
Mariam’s family initially resisted intervention, citing local customs.
Outcome:
Afghan authorities intervened after complaints from local NGOs.
The husband was prosecuted under EVAW Law provisions related to forced marriage and domestic abuse.
Mariam was placed under protective care and provided with educational support.
Significance:
The case showed enforcement challenges in areas with strong customary practices but also demonstrated the state’s commitment to protecting girls from forced marriage and violence.
3. Case of Ahmad and Ali (2015) — Child Labor and Trafficking
Background:
Ahmad and Ali, both under 14, were trafficked from a poor province to work in hazardous conditions in a city’s construction industry.
Legal Issues:
Child labor and trafficking violate Afghan law and international conventions.
The Juvenile Justice Law provides for protective measures for trafficked children.
Outcome:
The traffickers were arrested and prosecuted under Afghan trafficking and labor laws.
Ahmad and Ali were rescued and placed in child protection shelters.
The government worked with international agencies for their rehabilitation.
Significance:
This case highlighted enforcement efforts against child trafficking and labor exploitation and the cooperation between Afghan authorities and NGOs.
4. Case of Nasreen (2017) — Juvenile Justice and Detention Conditions
Background:
Nasreen, a 16-year-old girl, was arrested for theft and detained in an adult prison with poor conditions.
Legal Issues:
The Juvenile Justice Law mandates separate detention facilities and special treatment for juvenile offenders.
Nasreen’s detention violated these provisions, raising human rights concerns.
Outcome:
The Afghan Supreme Court ordered her transfer to a juvenile rehabilitation center.
The case prompted a review of detention conditions for juveniles nationwide.
The government increased efforts to implement juvenile justice standards.
Significance:
The case emphasized the importance of juvenile justice reforms and humane treatment of children in the criminal justice system.
5. Case of Bilal (2019) — Protection from Sexual Abuse in Schools
Background:
Bilal, a 12-year-old student, reported sexual abuse by a teacher at his school.
Legal Issues:
Sexual abuse of children is criminalized under Afghan law.
The case highlighted the need for child-friendly reporting mechanisms and protection policies in educational institutions.
Outcome:
The teacher was prosecuted and sentenced.
The Ministry of Education launched awareness campaigns and child protection policies in schools.
Bilal received counseling and support services.
Significance:
This case demonstrated progress in addressing sexual abuse of children and institutional reforms in education.
Summary Table
| Case | Year | Issue | Outcome/Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rahim | 2010 | Child soldier recruitment | Prosecution of recruiters, rehabilitation of child victim |
| Mariam | 2013 | Forced marriage, abuse | Prosecution under EVAW Law, protective care for victim |
| Ahmad and Ali | 2015 | Child labor and trafficking | Rescue, prosecution of traffickers, rehabilitation |
| Nasreen | 2017 | Juvenile detention rights | Supreme Court enforces juvenile justice standards |
| Bilal | 2019 | Sexual abuse in schools | Prosecution of perpetrator, education reforms |
Challenges in Enforcement of Child Protection Laws in Afghanistan
Cultural Norms and Customs: Traditional practices sometimes override legal protections (e.g., forced marriage).
Weak Judicial Capacity: Courts and police often lack training on child rights and juvenile justice.
Security Issues: Ongoing conflict hampers law enforcement and child protection services.
Limited Awareness: Many communities are unaware of children’s legal rights.
Institutional Gaps: Insufficient child-friendly facilities and social services.
Conclusion
Afghanistan’s child protection laws have made important strides, especially with the Juvenile Justice Law and EVAW Law. The cases above show increasing enforcement efforts in areas such as child soldiering, forced marriage, trafficking, juvenile justice, and protection from sexual abuse. However, persistent cultural, institutional, and security challenges require continued reform, training, and international support to fully realize the rights and protection of Afghan children.
RELATED Blog
0 comments