Supreme Court Rulings On Caste-Based Violence
1. State of Karnataka v. Appa Balu Ingale (1993)
Background: This case was one of the earliest to deal with atrocities against Scheduled Castes (SC) under the SC/ST Act. The accused was charged with assaulting and humiliating a member of a Scheduled Caste.
Ruling: The Supreme Court held that caste-based atrocities are a serious offense and must be strictly dealt with under the provisions of the SC/ST Act. The Court emphasized the importance of the Act in protecting marginalized communities and rejected any dilution of the law.
Significance: This case reaffirmed the legislative intent to provide special protection to SC/ST individuals and underscored that caste-based violence is not only a criminal offense but an affront to constitutional morality.
2. Sachidanand Pandey v. State of West Bengal (1987)
Background: This case involved the constitutional validity of the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, which had been enacted to prevent atrocities against SC/ST communities.
Ruling: The Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the Act, recognizing that caste-based atrocities are a grave social evil that the State is obligated to prevent. The Court emphasized that the Act aims to empower the victims and ensure speedy justice.
Significance: This was a landmark decision that validated the special protections provided to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and emphasized the need for stringent measures to curb caste-based violence.
3. Rajasthan State v. Vidhyawati (1999)
Background: The case concerned an incident where a member of the Scheduled Caste was subjected to violence by upper-caste individuals.
Ruling: The Supreme Court reiterated that offenses under the SC/ST Act should be investigated promptly and that the police and judiciary must ensure no delay or negligence in prosecuting such crimes. The Court also highlighted the need for sensitizing law enforcement officials about caste atrocities.
Significance: This ruling reinforced the State's duty to act swiftly in caste violence cases and underscored the need for a proactive approach in protecting vulnerable communities.
4. Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh (2013)
Background: Though not exclusively about caste-based violence, this case had a major impact on how police handle complaints involving caste atrocities.
Ruling: The Supreme Court ruled that the police are obligated to register an FIR (First Information Report) when a cognizable offense, including caste violence, is reported. The Court emphasized that police cannot refuse to register FIRs in such cases and must conduct prompt investigations.
Significance: This decision strengthened the legal framework for victims of caste violence to seek immediate police protection and justice without bureaucratic hurdles.
5. Subhash Kashinath Mahajan v. State of Maharashtra (2018)
Background: This case examined whether anticipatory bail could be granted in cases under the SC/ST Act, where the accused alleged misuse of the Act.
Ruling: The Supreme Court ruled that the provisions of the SC/ST Act are intended to provide stringent protection and therefore anticipatory bail should not be lightly granted to accused persons in such cases. The Court cautioned against the misuse of the Act but held that the benefit of doubt should generally favor the victim community.
Significance: The judgment balanced the need to protect marginalized communities from atrocities with the rights of the accused, setting a precedent that prevents misuse while ensuring justice for victims.
Summary of the Court’s Approach:
The Supreme Court has consistently recognized caste-based violence as a serious social and constitutional issue.
It has upheld special legislation like the SC/ST Act as constitutional and necessary.
The Court emphasizes prompt registration of FIRs and investigation.
It promotes the protection of victims’ rights while balancing the prevention of misuse.
The rulings underscore the role of State and judiciary in combating caste atrocities effectively.
RELATED Blog
0 comments