Conditions Requisite for the Initiation of Proceedings
Conditions Requisite for the Initiation of Criminal Proceedings
Introduction:
Before criminal proceedings can be initiated against any person, certain conditions must be satisfied to ensure that the process is just, fair, and legally valid. These conditions act as safeguards against frivolous or malicious prosecutions and protect the rights of the accused.
Types of Proceedings in Criminal Law:
Investigation: Preliminary inquiry by police.
Inquiry: Judicial examination before trial (by Magistrate).
Trial: Formal adjudication to determine guilt or innocence.
Conditions Requisite for Initiation of Criminal Proceedings:
Existence of a Cognizable Offense:
The complaint or FIR must allege a cognizable offense (where police can investigate without magistrate’s permission).
Non-cognizable offenses require permission of the magistrate.
Filing of First Information Report (FIR):
For cognizable offenses, police can begin investigation upon receiving an FIR.
FIR is the first information reported to police about a crime (Section 154, CrPC).
If FIR is false or frivolous, it can be quashed.
Complaint or Information:
A criminal complaint can be made by the aggrieved person or any citizen.
Under Section 190 CrPC, the Magistrate can take cognizance on complaint, police report, or information.
Cognizance by Magistrate:
Before trial, magistrate must take cognizance of the offense under Section 190.
Cognizance may be taken on police report, complaint, or otherwise.
Jurisdiction of Court:
The court where the case is initiated must have jurisdiction (territorial, pecuniary, and subject matter).
If not, proceedings can be quashed or transferred.
Sanction of Competent Authority (if required):
Certain offenses require prior sanction from a government authority before initiation (e.g., Public Servants under Section 197 CrPC, or under Prevention of Corruption Act).
No proceedings without valid sanction.
Compliance with Statutory Conditions:
Some statutes lay down preconditions before criminal proceedings (e.g., limitation period, filing complaint within prescribed time).
Prima Facie Case:
There must be a prima facie case against the accused to justify initiation.
Magistrate exercises discretion before issuing process.
Important Legal Provisions:
Section 154 CrPC: Registration of FIR.
Section 190 CrPC: Cognizance of offenses by Magistrate.
Section 197 CrPC: Sanction for prosecution of public servants.
Section 482 CrPC: High Court’s inherent powers to quash frivolous proceedings.
Leading Case Laws:
1. State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, AIR 1992 SC 604
Laid down parameters for quashing FIR or criminal proceedings.
Proceedings can be quashed if FIR is frivolous, malicious, or there is no prima facie case.
2. Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar, (2014) 8 SCC 273
Held that arrests must follow procedure and only when necessary.
Police should satisfy themselves about the truth of complaint before proceeding.
3. Lalita Kumari v. Govt. of UP, (2014) 2 SCC 1
Mandatory registration of FIR upon receiving information about cognizable offense.
Police cannot refuse to register FIR.
4. Kalyanpur Cement Ltd. v. Union of India, AIR 1989 SC 1237
Held that no criminal proceeding shall be initiated without sanction under statutory provisions.
5. R.K. Anand v. Delhi High Court, (2009) 8 SCC 106
Stressed importance of prima facie satisfaction by court before issuing summons or process.
6. Chakra Ram v. Union of India, AIR 1959 SC 308
Explained the role of Magistrate in taking cognizance and judicial control over investigation.
Summary Table:
| Condition | Explanation | Relevant Provisions & Cases |
|---|---|---|
| Cognizable offense | Offense warranting police investigation without magistrate permission | Section 2(c), Section 154 CrPC |
| Filing of FIR or complaint | Registration of first information or complaint | Section 154, Section 190 CrPC |
| Cognizance by Magistrate | Magistrate must take cognizance before trial | Section 190 CrPC, Chakra Ram case |
| Jurisdiction | Court must have territorial and subject matter jurisdiction | General principle of jurisdiction |
| Sanction for prosecution | Prior sanction required for public servants etc. | Section 197 CrPC, Kalyanpur Cement case |
| Prima facie case | Sufficient grounds to proceed with trial | R.K. Anand case, Bhajan Lal case |
| Compliance with statutory rules | Limitation period, prescribed procedure | Depends on specific statute |
Conclusion:
Initiation of criminal proceedings is a process governed by multiple safeguards to prevent misuse of law and protect individual rights. The courts play a critical role in ensuring that proceedings begin only when there is sufficient cause, proper jurisdiction, and compliance with legal provisions including sanction requirements. The conditions requisite also ensure a balance between the state’s duty to maintain law and order and the accused’s fundamental rights.
RELATED Blog
0 comments