Policing And Law Enforcement
I. OVERVIEW: POLICING AND LAW ENFORCEMENT IN AFGHANISTAN
Policing in Afghanistan has been shaped by decades of conflict, foreign involvement, and efforts at reform. It involves:
Law enforcement: Maintaining public order, enforcing laws, preventing and investigating crime.
Policing bodies:
Afghan National Police (ANP),
Afghan Local Police (now mostly disbanded),
Counter Narcotics Police,
Criminal Investigation Department (CID).
Police operate under:
Afghan Constitution,
Police Law (2005),
Criminal Procedure Code (2014),
And the Afghan Penal Code (2017).
II. KEY FUNCTIONS OF POLICE
Investigating crimes.
Arresting suspects according to due process.
Ensuring public safety and traffic control.
Supporting anti-terrorism and counter-narcotics operations.
Working with prosecutors to build criminal cases.
III. CASE LAW: POLICING AND ENFORCEMENT IN PRACTICE
Let’s explore more than five cases where police conduct — good or bad — had legal consequences or shaped law enforcement.
⚖️ Case 1: Police Failure to Protect — Bamyan Robbery Case (2015)
Facts: Police failed to respond to multiple reports of armed robberies in a rural village.
Issue: Local police were accused of negligence and possible collusion.
Legal Action: Prosecuted for dereliction of duty under the Penal Code.
Outcome: Two officers suspended; one found guilty and demoted.
Impact: Sparked debate about rural police accountability and capacity.
⚖️ Case 2: Excessive Use of Force — Kabul Protest Crackdown (2016)
Incident: Police used tear gas and live fire on protesters.
Legal Question: Was the use of force justified under Police Law Article 17 (use of force proportional to threat)?
Trial: Officers investigated by internal police review and Ministry of Interior.
Outcome: One commander convicted of abuse of authority.
Significance: Reinforced principle that police must use measured force.
⚖️ Case 3: Successful Investigation — Child Kidnapping in Herat (2017)
Event: Police quickly identified and rescued a kidnapped child through coordinated investigation.
Legal Action: Suspects were arrested lawfully, confessions obtained legally.
Trial: Led to successful conviction and 20-year sentences.
Impact: Highlighted effectiveness when police follow correct procedures.
⚖️ Case 4: Police Brutality — Kandahar Detention Case (2018)
Facts: Detainees reported torture and abuse in police custody.
Legal Issue: Violation of due process and Article 29 of the Constitution (prohibition of torture).
Investigation: Prosecutors filed criminal charges against officers.
Outcome: Three police convicted, one dismissed permanently.
Importance: Reinforced limits on police powers in pretrial detention.
⚖️ Case 5: Corruption in Licensing — Kabul Traffic Police (2019)
Facts: Officers accepted bribes to issue driving licenses.
Investigation: Internal affairs and ACJC uncovered widespread bribery.
Trial: Multiple officers prosecuted.
Outcome: Several convicted and dismissed.
Public Impact: Boosted demand for wider police reform.
⚖️ Case 6: Community Policing Success — Balkh Province (2020)
Initiative: Local police worked with elders and civil society to reduce crime.
Result: Crime rate dropped by 30% in the area.
Case: A community-supported arrest of a gang leader led to a model prosecution.
Significance: Showed importance of community trust and cooperation.
IV. LEGAL PRINCIPLES FROM THESE CASES
| Legal Principle | Seen In Case(s) |
|---|---|
| Proportional use of force | Protest crackdown (2016) |
| Due process in arrest | Herat kidnapping case (2017), Kandahar detention (2018) |
| Accountability of officers | Bamyan failure case (2015), corruption case (2019) |
| Community engagement | Balkh community policing (2020) |
| Protection of detainee rights | Kandahar police brutality (2018) |
V. SUMMARY TABLE
| Case | Issue | Outcome | Importance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bamyan Robbery Negligence (2015) | Police failed to respond | Demotion, suspension | Accountability in rural policing |
| Kabul Protest Force (2016) | Excessive force on civilians | Conviction of commander | Limits of force under law |
| Herat Kidnapping (2017) | Quick lawful arrest | Conviction of suspects | Shows good practice in policing |
| Kandahar Detention (2018) | Torture of detainees | Officers convicted/dismissed | Reinforces rights of suspects |
| Traffic Corruption (2019) | Bribes for licenses | Convictions and firings | Exposes systemic corruption |
| Balkh Community Policing (2020) | Collaboration with citizens | Reduced crime, public trust | Highlights community-based solutions |
RELATED Blog
0 comments