Police Accountability And Criminal Liability
Police Accountability and Criminal Liability: Overview
Police officers have powers to enforce laws, but when they misuse authority—through brutality, corruption, unlawful arrest, or violation of rights—they can face criminal liability. Accountability mechanisms include:
Internal disciplinary actions
Criminal prosecutions (state or federal)
Civil suits (not covered here, but important)
Case Studies Explaining Police Accountability and Criminal Liability
1. Case of Rodney King Beating (1991, Los Angeles)
Facts: Rodney King was brutally beaten by LAPD officers after a traffic stop. Video evidence sparked national outrage.
Charges: Officers were charged with excessive use of force and assault.
Outcome: Initial acquittals led to riots, but federal civil rights charges later led to convictions of some officers.
Significance: Landmark in showing how video evidence and federal oversight can hold police criminally liable for brutality.
2. Case of Abner Louima (1997, New York)
Facts: Louima was assaulted and tortured by NYPD officers while in custody.
Criminal Charges: Officers faced assault and civil rights violation charges.
Outcome: Several officers convicted; prison sentences imposed.
Lesson: Demonstrated zero tolerance policy for custodial torture under U.S. law, reinforcing police liability.
3. Case of Eric Garner (2014, New York)
Facts: Garner died after an officer used a banned chokehold during an arrest for selling loose cigarettes.
Legal Process: Criminal charges against the officer were declined, but civil rights investigations followed.
Impact: Sparked reforms on use-of-force policies and public debate on police accountability.
Takeaway: Highlights challenges in prosecuting officers even in high-profile deaths.
4. Case of Derek Chauvin – George Floyd Killing (2020, Minneapolis)
Facts: Chauvin, a police officer, knelt on Floyd’s neck causing death. The act was filmed globally.
Criminal Charges: Second-degree murder, third-degree murder, and manslaughter.
Outcome: Convicted on all charges, sentenced to over 20 years.
Significance: Historic criminal accountability for police killing, showing growing public and legal intolerance of police violence.
5. Case of Samuel DuBose (2015, Cincinnati)
Facts: Police officer shot unarmed DuBose during a traffic stop.
Criminal Proceedings: Officer charged with murder and voluntary manslaughter.
Outcome: Officer acquitted by jury but fired from the department.
Significance: Illustrates difficulties in securing convictions despite serious charges; accountability includes employment consequences.
6. Case of Laquan McDonald (2014, Chicago)
Facts: Laquan was shot 16 times by Officer Van Dyke; dashcam video contradicted police reports.
Charges: Murder and aggravated battery against the officer.
Outcome: Officer convicted and sentenced to prison.
Lesson: Video evidence crucial for accountability; led to police reforms in Chicago.
Summary Table
| Case | Jurisdiction | Police Misconduct | Charges | Outcome | Key Lesson |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rodney King | California | Brutal beating | Assault, civil rights violations | Some convictions on federal charges | Video evidence can enforce accountability |
| Abner Louima | New York | Torture in custody | Assault, civil rights violations | Multiple convictions | Zero tolerance for torture |
| Eric Garner | New York | Use of banned chokehold | No criminal charges filed | Public outcry, policy reform | Difficulty in prosecuting police |
| Derek Chauvin | Minnesota | Murder of George Floyd | Murder, manslaughter | Convicted, sentenced | Strong accountability precedent |
| Samuel DuBose | Ohio | Shooting during traffic stop | Murder, manslaughter | Acquitted, fired | Legal challenges in prosecution |
| Laquan McDonald | Illinois | Multiple gunshots | Murder, aggravated battery | Convicted, sentenced | Dashcam crucial for truth |
Key Points to Remember
Evidence (video, witness testimony) is critical for holding police criminally liable.
Prosecutors face challenges like qualified immunity and public pressure.
Accountability is a mix of criminal trials, departmental discipline, and sometimes federal civil rights enforcement.
Landmark cases have influenced reforms in use-of-force policies and training.
RELATED Blog
0 comments