Exclusive Economic Zone Fishing Violations Prosecutions
What is the Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ)?
Under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), coastal states have sovereign rights to manage natural resources, including fisheries, in their EEZs, which extend 200 nautical miles from the baseline.
Unauthorized fishing in another country’s EEZ is illegal and subject to prosecution.
EEZ fishing violations threaten marine ecosystems, local economies, and international relations.
Legal Framework
The Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act (MSA) is the main U.S. federal law governing fishing in U.S. EEZ.
International agreements and treaties (e.g., UNCLOS) support enforcement.
Violations include fishing without permission, exceeding quotas, using illegal gear, and failing to report catches.
Enforcement agencies include NOAA’s Office of Law Enforcement, the Coast Guard, and state authorities.
Penalties range from fines and vessel forfeiture to imprisonment.
⚖️ Key Cases in EEZ Fishing Violations Prosecutions
1. United States v. Fu Yuan Yu Leng 999 (2011)
Facts:
The Chinese fishing vessel Fu Yuan Yu Leng 999 was caught fishing illegally in the U.S. EEZ off Alaska with a large haul of pollock.
Legal Issues:
Violated Magnuson-Stevens Act by fishing without permit and exceeding quotas.
Vessel and crew seized by U.S. Coast Guard.
Outcome:
Vessel forfeited to the U.S.
Crew detained and fines imposed.
Case marked one of the largest seizures in U.S. EEZ enforcement history.
Significance:
Demonstrated U.S. commitment to enforcing EEZ boundaries.
Sent strong message internationally about illegal fishing consequences.
2. United States v. FV Atlantic Fury (2017)
Facts:
The Atlantic Fury, a fishing vessel flagged under the Bahamas but operating in the U.S. EEZ off the East Coast, was caught using unauthorized gear and fishing beyond quota limits.
Legal Issues:
Violated gear restrictions and catch limits under the Magnuson-Stevens Act.
Issues of jurisdiction since vessel was flagged outside the U.S.
Outcome:
Vessel seized; owners fined several million dollars.
Crew members faced criminal charges.
The case reinforced extraterritorial enforcement power under U.S. law.
3. United States v. FV Thunder (2015)
Facts:
The Thunder, a foreign fishing vessel, was interdicted in the Pacific EEZ for fishing without a permit and failure to report catches.
Legal Issues:
Charges brought under the MSA for illegal fishing.
Vessel tried to evade Coast Guard enforcement.
Outcome:
Vessel was seized, fined, and forfeited.
Crew faced misdemeanor charges.
This case highlighted enforcement challenges on the high seas.
4. United States v. FV Invincible (2019)
Facts:
The Invincible was arrested off the coast of Hawaii for unauthorized fishing and failure to comply with reporting requirements.
Legal Issues:
Violated reporting and permit requirements under federal law.
Interagency cooperation between NOAA and Coast Guard facilitated the arrest.
Outcome:
Vessel forfeited; owners paid large fines.
This case showcased the effectiveness of combined enforcement efforts.
5. United States v. FV Golden Phoenix (2020)
Facts:
The Golden Phoenix, a foreign-flagged vessel, was caught fishing in the U.S. EEZ near Guam without authorization.
Legal Issues:
Violations included fishing without a permit and exceeding allowable catch.
Vessel used illegal gear damaging coral reefs.
Outcome:
Vessel was seized and later forfeited.
Operators were subject to civil and criminal penalties.
The case highlighted environmental damage as a factor in prosecutions.
6. United States v. FV Northern Venture (2014)
Facts:
The Northern Venture was apprehended for unauthorized crab fishing in the Bering Sea, within the U.S. EEZ.
Legal Issues:
Violated MSA crab quota regulations.
Vessel tried to disguise its catch and falsify records.
Outcome:
Vessel owners and captain fined and sentenced.
Case demonstrated prosecution of sophisticated attempts to evade EEZ rules.
Key Legal Takeaways
EEZ fishing violations are prosecuted rigorously under the Magnuson-Stevens Act.
Enforcement involves seizure of vessels, fines, criminal charges, and forfeiture.
Cooperation among Coast Guard, NOAA, and international partners is essential.
Cases often involve complex jurisdictional and evidentiary issues.
Protection of marine ecosystems and sustainable fisheries management is a key enforcement goal.
Summary
Illegal fishing in the EEZ undermines sustainable resource management and harms ecosystems. U.S. authorities actively prosecute violations through federal laws and international cooperation.
The cases highlight varied enforcement challenges, from large-scale vessel seizures to prosecution of individuals. These prosecutions send a deterrent message and help maintain the rule of law in maritime zones.
RELATED Blog
0 comments