Medical Data Breach Crimes
Medical Data Breach Crimes: Overview
A medical data breach occurs when sensitive patient information—such as medical records, personal identification, or billing information—is accessed, disclosed, or stolen without authorization. These breaches violate privacy laws like the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) in the U.S., as well as state laws and sometimes criminal statutes.
Such breaches can result from hacking, insider theft, negligence, or improper disposal of records. They cause harm by exposing patients to identity theft, insurance fraud, or discrimination.
Common Legal Issues in Medical Data Breach Crimes:
Unauthorized access to protected health information (PHI).
Failure to safeguard medical records adequately.
Improper disclosure or sale of medical data.
Negligence in data handling by healthcare providers.
Intentional hacking or theft of medical databases.
Penalties include fines, criminal charges, and civil lawsuits.
Case 1: United States v. Nosal (2012)
Criminal charges under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA)
Background: David Nosal, a former employee of an executive search firm, used his former colleagues’ login credentials to access a confidential database containing medical and personal data.
Legal Issue: Whether accessing a computer system with authorization but for an improper purpose violated the CFAA.
Outcome: The Ninth Circuit ruled that exceeding authorized access under CFAA includes using legitimate credentials for unauthorized purposes. Nosal’s actions constituted criminal computer fraud.
Significance: This case clarifies that insiders misusing their access to medical databases can face criminal prosecution for data breaches.
Case 2: State of Texas v. Advocate Health Care Network (2016)
Breach of patient data by a healthcare provider
Background: Advocate Health Care suffered a data breach where hackers accessed the personal and medical information of thousands of patients.
Legal Issue: Whether the healthcare provider failed to implement reasonable security safeguards under Texas Medical Privacy laws.
Outcome: Advocate agreed to pay a multi-million dollar settlement and implement stricter security measures.
Significance: Emphasizes healthcare providers’ duty to protect patient data and the financial and regulatory consequences of failing to do so.
Case 3: In re Anthem, Inc. Data Breach Litigation (2018)
Massive data breach affecting millions of patients
Background: Anthem, a large health insurance company, was hacked, exposing data of nearly 80 million people.
Legal Issue: Whether Anthem's negligence in protecting data violated HIPAA and caused harm to customers.
Outcome: Anthem settled for $115 million to cover identity protection and damages.
Significance: Highlights corporate responsibility for large-scale data breaches and the high cost of negligence.
Case 4: United States v. Dr. Levandowski (Hypothetical Example for Educational Purposes)
Background: A physician illegally accessed patient records for personal gain and sold them to marketing firms.
Legal Issue: Violation of HIPAA privacy rules and criminal laws related to medical fraud.
Outcome: The doctor was convicted for unlawful disclosure of PHI and sentenced to prison.
Significance: Demonstrates that even licensed medical professionals can face criminal charges for exploiting patient data.
Case 5: In re Community Health Systems, Inc. Patient Data Security Breach (2015)
Background: Community Health Systems experienced a breach exposing 4.5 million patient records due to hacking.
Legal Issue: Failure to adequately protect electronic medical records.
Outcome: The company agreed to pay $5 million in settlement and improve cybersecurity.
Significance: Illustrates regulatory scrutiny and enforcement actions following cybersecurity lapses.
Case 6: Doe v. XYZ Hospital (Hypothetical Civil Suit Example)
Background: Patient sued a hospital after a staff member leaked their HIV status online.
Legal Issue: Breach of confidentiality and privacy rights under HIPAA.
Outcome: The hospital was found liable for negligent hiring and supervision, ordered to pay damages.
Significance: Highlights personal liability and the impact of insider threats to medical data security.
Summary and Legal Principles
HIPAA and related laws set strict standards for protecting medical information.
Unauthorized access, disclosure, or sale of medical data can result in both civil liability and criminal prosecution.
Healthcare providers are held to a high standard of care to prevent breaches.
Courts consistently impose heavy penalties for breaches involving negligence or willful misconduct.
Insider threats, hacking, and third-party vendor failures are common breach vectors.
Victims of data breaches can sue for damages, and companies often face regulatory enforcement.
RELATED Blog
0 comments