Penology in Comoros
Penology in the Comoros faces significant challenges, particularly concerning prison conditions, the treatment of detainees, and the broader criminal justice system.
Prison Conditions
The prison system in the Comoros is characterized by severe overcrowding, inadequate infrastructure, and poor living conditions. Moroni Prison, the largest in the country, has a capacity of 60 inmates but often holds over 350, leading to cramped and unsanitary conditions. Detainees typically receive only one meager meal per day, and many rely on family visits for additional food. The facilities suffer from inadequate sanitation, limited access to potable water, and insufficient medical care. Reports indicate that 80% of prisoners may have scabies, and the lack of proper ventilation and lighting exacerbates the harsh environment .(ecoi.net, Refworld, Refworld, Prison Insider)
Juvenile Detention
The legal framework in the Comoros treats juveniles over the age of 13 as adults within the criminal justice system. However, authorities often release juveniles under the age of 15 to the custody of their parents if they are not repeat offenders. Despite this, juveniles are still held with adults in detention facilities, raising concerns about their safety and rehabilitation .(Refworld, Refworld)
Legal Framework and Penal Code
The Comorian Penal Code classifies offenses into three categories: minor offenses, offenses, and crimes. Penalties range from fines and short-term imprisonment to corporal punishment and loss of civil rights. While the death penalty is legally sanctioned, it has not been utilized since the 1990s, indicating a de facto moratorium on capital punishment .(IMF eLibrary, Wikipedia)
Human Rights and International Oversight
Prison conditions have drawn criticism from international bodies. The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) has been granted access to monitor and improve conditions in Comorian prisons, including providing hygiene products and facilitating family visits. However, reports of ill-treatment persist, and in 2019, the UN Special Rapporteur on Torture was denied access to detention sites in Moroni and Anjouan .(International Committee of the Red Cross, Global Detention Project)
Political and Arbitrary Detention
There have been instances of political prisoners and detainees in the Comoros, with reports of individuals being detained for organizing political demonstrations or expressing dissenting views. The government has occasionally pardoned individuals convicted of anti-government actions, but concerns about arbitrary detention and the treatment of political prisoners remain .(ecoi.net)
Recent Developments
In April 2024, 38 inmates escaped from Moroni Prison, reportedly due to negligence by security guards. This incident underscores ongoing issues with prison management and security .(Reuters)
Conclusion
Penology in the Comoros is marked by systemic issues including overcrowded and unsanitary prison conditions, inadequate legal protections for juveniles, and concerns about political and arbitrary detention. While international organizations like the ICRC have made efforts to improve conditions, significant reforms are needed to ensure the protection of detainees' rights and the establishment of a more just and humane penal system.(International Committee of the Red Cross)
RELATED Blog
0 comments