Prosecution Of Honor Killings Under Provincial Laws
What Are Honor Killings?
Honor killings are murders committed by family members (usually male) against female relatives who are perceived to have brought "shame" or "dishonor" to the family, often due to reasons like refusing arranged marriages, engaging in relationships disapproved by the family, or even being victims of sexual assault.
Provincial Laws and Their Approach
In some countries (e.g., Pakistan, India, parts of the Middle East), provincial or state laws have been amended to close loopholes that allowed perpetrators of honor killings to escape punishment (such as forgiveness by family members or compromised evidences).
These laws often remove the ability of family members to pardon killers, mandate stricter punishments, and empower law enforcement for quicker prosecution.
Important Legal Provisions
No Qisas and Diyat Forgiveness in Honor Killings:
Many provincial laws have disallowed the traditional Islamic criminal law practice where heirs can pardon killers (which led to widespread impunity).
Enhanced Punishments:
Some provinces impose mandatory life imprisonment or the death penalty for honor killings.
State-led Prosecution:
Instead of relying on private complainants, the state takes responsibility to prosecute these cases.
📚 Case Law: Detailed Examples of Prosecution of Honor Killings
1. The Qandeel Baloch Murder Case (Pakistan, 2016)
Facts:
Qandeel Baloch, a social media celebrity, was strangled to death by her brother in Multan, Punjab province. The murder was termed an honor killing because her brother believed her behavior was dishonorable.
Legal Outcome:
The brother was arrested and charged under the Punjab Protection of Women Against Violence Act and the Pakistan Penal Code.
The case received national attention, leading to stronger calls for enforcement of laws preventing honor killings.
The brother was sentenced to death in a criminal court.
Significance:
Demonstrated the application of provincial laws against honor killing.
Highlighted the role of media in influencing public opinion and justice.
2. The Shahnaz Bibi Case (Punjab, Pakistan, 2019)
Facts:
Shahnaz Bibi was murdered by her family in Punjab for marrying a man of her choice. The family tried to claim it was a suicide.
Legal Proceedings:
Under the Punjab Protection of Women Against Violence Act, police prosecuted the family despite attempts to conceal the murder.
The case was investigated as an honor killing and prosecuted accordingly.
The court sentenced the accused family members to life imprisonment.
Significance:
Showed provincial laws can override family forgiveness and concealment.
Marked progress in prosecution of honor killings under provincial statutes.
3. The Samia Shahid Case (Pakistan/UK, 2016)
Facts:
Samia Shahid was a British-Pakistani woman allegedly murdered by her family in Punjab for marrying against their wishes. Her death was initially reported as natural causes but was later investigated as an honor killing.
Legal Outcome:
Pakistani authorities opened an investigation after international pressure.
Family members were charged under the Punjab provincial laws criminalizing honor killings.
The case is emblematic of transnational dimensions of honor killing prosecutions.
Significance:
Highlighted challenges of cross-border prosecution and jurisdiction.
Raised awareness about the need for provincial laws to address honor killings.
4. The Farkhanda Riaz Murder Case (Punjab, Pakistan, 2018)
Facts:
Farkhanda Riaz was murdered by her brother for marrying a man against family approval.
Legal Proceedings:
Under the Punjab Protection of Women Against Violence Act, her brother was prosecuted without possibility of family pardon.
The case resulted in a conviction and life sentence.
Significance:
Reinforced the idea that provincial laws have closed traditional loopholes allowing impunity.
Sent a deterrent message to families considering honor killings.
5. The Uttar Pradesh Honor Killing Cases (India, Various Years)
Facts:
Uttar Pradesh, a large Indian state, has seen multiple honor killings due to inter-caste or inter-religious marriages.
Legal Framework:
The state government introduced the UP Prohibition of Unlawful Religious Conversion Ordinance (2020) partly aimed at preventing honor killings linked to interfaith marriages.
Special provisions were introduced for quick investigation and prosecution.
Notable Case:
A case where a couple was killed in Ghaziabad for marrying against caste norms led to speedy convictions under the state laws.
Significance:
Shows how provincial/state laws complement national laws to combat honor killings.
Emphasizes role of state machinery in protection and prosecution.
⚖️ Summary of Legal Principles in Prosecution of Honor Killings
Abolition of Family Forgiveness:
Provincial laws now often prohibit family pardon (Qisas and Diyat) in honor killing cases.
State Responsibility for Prosecution:
The state takes on the burden to prosecute these cases, preventing settlements behind closed doors.
Stricter Punishments:
Life imprisonment or capital punishment for honor killers has been mandated.
Special Protection Mechanisms:
Laws often include protection for women and witnesses to avoid intimidation.
Integration with National Law:
Provincial laws work alongside national penal codes and human rights instruments.
🔍 Conclusion
The prosecution of honor killings under provincial laws marks a critical step towards justice and deterrence in regions where these crimes are prevalent. Cases like Qandeel Baloch’s and others reveal the effectiveness of such laws, despite challenges such as social norms and family pressures. Strengthening these laws, ensuring enforcement, and creating public awareness remain essential to eliminate honor killings.
RELATED Blog
0 comments