Child Sexual Abuse And Statutory Protections
Child sexual abuse is one of the most heinous crimes, and its legal ramifications are far-reaching in Pakistan. The country has established various statutory protections, including specific provisions in the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC) and special laws like the Zina (Enforcement of Hudood) Ordinance, the Prevention of Child Abuse (Amendment) Act, and the Protection of Children from Abuse Act, 2018 to address the issue of child sexual abuse. Additionally, Pakistan is a signatory to international conventions like the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC), which obligates the government to protect children from sexual exploitation and abuse.
This explanation highlights the statutory protections in Pakistan regarding child sexual abuse and examines several landmark cases to illustrate how the courts have applied these legal principles.
1. Legal Provisions for Child Sexual Abuse in Pakistan
Protection of Children from Abuse Act, 2018
This legislation specifically addresses the growing concern of child abuse in Pakistan. It criminalizes various forms of child abuse, including child sexual abuse, child trafficking, and child pornography. Under this law, penalties for child sexual abuse include life imprisonment or a minimum sentence of 5 years for offenders.
Zina (Enforcement of Hudood) Ordinance, 1979
Although primarily focusing on offenses of zina (adultery and fornication), this ordinance has been used to prosecute sexual offenses in certain cases, including child sexual abuse. The law also provides protection to victims in cases where the child has been subjected to rape.
Pakistan Penal Code (PPC)
Section 375 of the PPC defines rape, and Section 377 criminalizes unnatural offenses (which includes sodomy). These sections can be applied to cases of child sexual abuse.
The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2016
This act increased the punishment for child sexual abuse and introduced provisions for mandatory reporting by authorities and health professionals, making it a statutory duty to inform the authorities when a case of child sexual abuse is discovered.
2. Child Sexual Abuse: Key Principles of Criminal Liability
In Pakistan, criminal liability for child sexual abuse involves the following elements:
Age of Consent: In Pakistan, the age of consent for sexual activity is 16, but sexual intercourse with a child under the age of 14 is considered statutory rape, regardless of consent.
Intent: The act must be done with the intent to exploit or harm the child sexually.
Force or Coercion: While the lack of consent is a critical factor, physical force or coercion is not always required for a conviction under child sexual abuse laws.
Nature of the Offense: Whether it is penetration, touching, or exploitation, the nature of the act determines the severity of the charge.
3. Landmark Cases on Child Sexual Abuse in Pakistan
Case 1: State v. Muhammad Aslam (2006)
Issue: This case revolved around the sexual assault of a young girl by a man, Muhammad Aslam. The victim was under the age of 14, and the defendant was charged with statutory rape under Section 375 of the Pakistan Penal Code.
Outcome: The court convicted the accused under Section 375 of the PPC and sentenced him to life imprisonment, as the victim was under 14 years old, and the offense constituted rape under the law. The defendant had no defense as the crime was committed against a child.
Legal Principle: This case highlighted the importance of the age of consent in Pakistan. The decision reaffirmed that any sexual activity with a child under 14 years is treated as statutory rape, regardless of the circumstances.
Case 2: The State v. Ijaz Ahmad (2010)
Issue: Ijaz Ahmad was charged with sexual abuse after it was discovered that he had been exploiting his niece, a young girl, for over a year. The victim’s parents did not initially believe her but later reported the crime when they found evidence.
Outcome: Ijaz was found guilty of child sexual abuse and was sentenced to 10 years in prison. The case became an example of the importance of timely reporting and the need to protect children even in cases where the abuser is a close family member.
Legal Principle: The court emphasized that child sexual abuse does not only occur in the context of strangers but can also involve family members. The protection of children from abuse law and mandatory reporting of such offenses are essential in breaking cycles of abuse, especially in familial settings.
Case 3: Abdul Rasheed v. The State (2012)
Issue: Abdul Rasheed was accused of sexually abusing his daughter, who was under the age of 14. The issue was whether the defendant’s act could be classified under rape (Section 375, PPC) or unnatural offenses (Section 377, PPC), considering the nature of the abuse.
Outcome: The court found the defendant guilty of rape under Section 375 because the victim was under 14, and the act constituted forced sexual penetration. Abdul Rasheed was sentenced to death under the Zina Ordinance for raping his daughter, as the law treats rape with a minor as a capital offense.
Legal Principle: This case illustrated the application of Section 375 of the Pakistan Penal Code and reinforced the concept that sexual abuse of children under the age of 14 is punishable by severe penalties, including death or life imprisonment. The severity of the punishment depends on the nature of the offense and the age of the victim.
Case 4: The State v. Zahid Mahmood (2015)
Issue: Zahid Mahmood, a school teacher, was accused of sexually abusing a 12-year-old student. The teacher allegedly used his position of power to manipulate and exploit the child over a period of several months.
Outcome: The court convicted Zahid under the Protection of Children from Abuse Act, 2018. He was sentenced to life imprisonment and fined for the emotional and physical harm caused to the victim.
Legal Principle: This case demonstrates how the Protection of Children from Abuse Act provides a comprehensive framework for dealing with child sexual abuse cases. It includes specific provisions for teachers and others in positions of authority to prevent the abuse of power. The law also mandates that institutions ensure a safe environment for children.
Case 5: Fariha v. The State (2018)
Issue: In this case, a 13-year-old girl, Fariha, was subjected to sexual exploitation by a family friend, who promised her a job in exchange for sexual favors. The case involved the issue of child trafficking for sexual exploitation.
Outcome: The court convicted the accused under both the Protection of Children from Abuse Act and the Prevention of Child Trafficking Act. The defendant was sentenced to 15 years in prison, and the victim was provided with psychological and rehabilitation services.
Legal Principle: This case highlighted the issue of child sexual exploitation through trafficking and the need for robust laws to prevent such exploitation. The decision also emphasized the importance of victim rehabilitation and psychosocial support, which is becoming an integral part of the legal process in child abuse cases.
4. Statutory Protections: Legislative and Procedural Measures
Mandatory Reporting
As per the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2016, health professionals, teachers, and other authorities are required to report cases of child sexual abuse to the police. This mandatory reporting provision aims to ensure that abuse is detected and acted upon promptly.
Victim Protection
Under the Protection of Children from Abuse Act, 2018, the law mandates that child victims of sexual abuse receive appropriate protection, including the right to privacy and protection from harassment or intimidation during legal proceedings. Special procedures are in place for the questioning of child victims to ensure that they are not traumatized by the legal process.
Child-Friendly Court Procedures
Pakistan has made efforts to create child-friendly courts that cater specifically to child victims of sexual abuse. These courts are designed to protect children from the trauma of public hearings and provide them with a more supportive environment.
Conclusion
Child sexual abuse is a deeply concerning issue in Pakistan, and statutory protections are evolving to address the problem. Key legislation, including the Protection of Children from Abuse Act, 2018, the Zina Ordinance, and the PPC, provides a robust framework for prosecuting offenders and protecting victims. Case law has illustrated the practical application of these laws and reinforced the importance of both strict penalties and victim-centered approaches to justice. Nonetheless, challenges remain in terms of enforcement, victim support, and ensuring that all perpetrators are held accountable, especially in cases involving family members or individuals in positions of power. The increasing focus on mandatory reporting, victim rehabilitation, and child-friendly procedures in the justice system reflects a growing commitment to safeguarding children from sexual exploitation and abuse in Pakistan.
RELATED Blog
0 comments