Difference Between Equality Before Law and Equal Protection of Law
Difference Between Equality Before Law and Equal Protection of Law
1. Conceptual Understanding
Equality Before Law
Meaning: It means that no person is above the law; everyone, irrespective of their status, is subject to the same laws and legal procedures.
It is a negative concept, implying the absence of privilege or immunity.
It ensures that the law applies equally to all without favoritism or discrimination.
The term is derived from the English Common Law principle.
Emphasizes uniformity in legal obligations and liabilities.
Equal Protection of Law
Meaning: It means that laws should be equally applicable and enforced in the same manner for all persons who are similarly situated.
It is a positive concept, emphasizing fairness, nondiscrimination, and justice.
Ensures that the State treats equals equally and unequals unequally in relevant respects.
Originates from the American Constitutional Law (Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment).
Implies that the law should not only be equal in letter but also in application and enforcement.
2. Scope and Emphasis
| Aspect | Equality Before Law | Equal Protection of Law |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Negative (absence of privilege/immunity) | Positive (fair and just treatment) |
| Focus | Uniform application of law to all persons | Fair application and enforcement according to circumstances |
| Origin | English Common Law | American Constitutional Law (14th Amendment) |
| What it prohibits | Arbitrary privilege or exemption from law | Discriminatory laws or discriminatory application |
| Application | Applies to the existence of law and procedure | Applies to the content and enforcement of law |
3. Article 14 of the Indian Constitution
Article 14 states: "The State shall not deny to any person equality before the law or the equal protection of the laws within the territory of India."
This means the Indian Constitution incorporates both concepts.
It guarantees no one is above law (formal equality) and also laws must be enforced equally and fairly (substantive equality).
4. Illustration
Suppose the law prescribes a fine of Rs. 100 for a certain offense.
Equality before law means that everyone must pay Rs. 100 for committing the offense—no one is exempt.
Equal protection of law means that if two persons commit the offense under similar circumstances, the law must impose the same penalty and not discriminate between them based on caste, religion, or status.
5. Relevant Case Law
A. A.K. Kraipak v. Union of India (1969)
The Supreme Court held that equality before law prohibits arbitrary or discriminatory treatment by public authorities.
Emphasized that equal protection of laws requires reasonableness and fairness in administrative action.
B. Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978)
The Court expanded the scope of Article 14, stating it includes the principle of reasonableness and non-arbitrariness.
It ruled that equal protection of law involves fair and just laws, not just formal equality.
C. E.P. Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu (1974)
The Court elaborated on Article 14 as a dynamic concept embracing equality and non-arbitrariness.
Reinforced that equal protection means equal treatment of equals in relevant circumstances.
D. State of West Bengal v. Anwar Ali Sarkar (1952)
The Court struck down a law that arbitrarily discriminated between citizens.
It highlighted the importance of both equality before law and equal protection of law.
6. Summary of Differences
| Feature | Equality Before Law | Equal Protection of Law |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Uniform application of law to all | Fair and nondiscriminatory application |
| Nature | Negative (absence of privilege) | Positive (justice and fairness) |
| Requirement | No one is above the law | Equal treatment of equals, differential treatment of unequals |
| Emphasis | Formal equality | Substantive equality |
| Source | English Common Law | U.S. Constitution (14th Amendment) |
| Enforcement | Applies to laws and legal procedure | Applies to laws and their administration |
7. Conclusion
Equality before law ensures everyone is subject to the same laws, preventing arbitrary privileges.
Equal protection of law ensures that laws are applied and enforced fairly and without discrimination, accommodating differences where relevant.
RELATED Blog
0 comments