West Virginia Code of State Rules Agency 8 - Hearing Aid Dealers
Overview: Purpose & Scope
The state of West Virginia regulates hearing‑aid dealers and fitters to protect public health and safety, ensuring that people selling, fitting, or dispensing hearing aids meet certain standards. Agency 8 (along with the statute Article 26 of Chapter 30, “Hearing‑Aid Dealers and Fitters”) sets out the licensing requirements, ethical obligations, disclosure duties, consumer protections, disciplinary procedures, and other regulations for licensees.
The rules are promulgated by the Board of Hearing Aid Dealers (though note there’s been legislative change moving some of these responsibilities). These regulations ensure that:
Persons dispensing hearing aids are properly qualified;
Consumers are informed (especially about medical aspects);
There is recourse if hearing aids are defective or service is unsatisfactory;
Rules about advertising, licensure, recordkeeping, etc., are followed.
Key Statutory Provisions (WV Code, Chapter 30, Article 26)
Here are the fundamental statutory rules underpinning Agency 8:
Definitions (WV Code § 30‑26‑1): What counts as a “hearing aid,” what is a “dealer or fitter,” what “practice of dealing or fitting” includes (e.g. testing, taking earmold impressions, selecting/fitting aids), who is a “trainee.” West Virginia Code
Licensure / Prohibition on Unlicensed Practice (§ 30‑26‑2): No person may engage in the practice (selling, fitting) of hearing aids, advertise or represent themselves as doing so, without being licensed (or a trainee) under the statute. There are exemptions (e.g. persons in training, some hearing tests without sale). West Virginia Code
Board Creation and Powers (§ 30‑26‑3): Establishes the Board, its composition (members include medical licensee, audiologist, experienced dealers/fitters), terms, duties (exams, licensing, rules, ethical standards) etc. West Virginia Code
Application / Qualifications (§ 30‑26‑5): To obtain a license: permanent office, good moral character, age, minimum education, free from certain diseases, no indictments for certain crimes. West Virginia Code
Matters to be Ascertained by Licensee Prior to Sale / Fitting (§ 30‑26‑14): Before fitting to minors, there must be a physician examination within 6 months, or else the licensee must delay; for adults, the person may waive medical evaluation, but certain conditions require medical referral/disclosure. Also, writings must be retained 7 years. Justia Law+2regulations.justia.com+2
Receipt & Right to Rescind (§ 30‑26‑15): The dealer must give a receipt with specific information (make/model, license number, terms) and consumers have the right to return (“rescind”) the aid within 30 days if dissatisfied (subject to certain conditions). FindLaw Codes
Posting License, Renewal, Reciprocity, etc. For example, § 30‑26‑8 requires display of license, duplicates; renewal duties; continuing education; etc. Reciprocity from similar licensing in other states if standards met. West Virginia Code+2West Virginia Code+2
Prohibited Acts & Penalties (§ 30‑26‑17, § 30‑26‑18): Among prohibited acts are false advertising, practicing without license, using fraudulent or altered license, mail‑order sales except under certain exception etc. Penalties for misdemeanors, fines, imprisonment, injunctive relief also possible. West Virginia Code
Rulemaking, Hearings, Judicial Review: The Board is authorized to adopt rules under article 29‑A, conduct hearings, grant disciplinary actions, and affected persons have the right to judicial review. West Virginia Code
Key Provisions in Agency 8 Regulations (Legislative Rules)
Agency 8 (Rule Governing the West Virginia Board of Hearing Aid Dealers) fleshes out how the statutory provisions are to be implemented. Some important elements:
Series 8‑01: General rules, licensing, duties of licensees, disclosure to buyers, the form and timing of disclosures. For example, Section 8‑1‑7 requires written disclosure that the dealer’s examination is not a medical diagnosis, and for minors under 18 medical evaluation from an otolaryngologist is required. regulations.justia.com
Series 8‑02, 8‑03: Procedures for contested case hearings; disciplinary/complaint procedures. These define how complaints are filed, how licensees are disciplined, what standards are used. (Exact rules in these series fill in timeframes, notice, representation, etc.) regulations.justia.com
Series 8‑05: Considering prior criminal convictions in license determinations. This addresses when past convictions may disqualify or require evaluation of character. regulations.justia.com
Rules about record-keeping, test methods (pure tone, masking, speech recognition, etc.), retention of examination results, etc. Wv Speech and Audiology+1
Consumer Protections & Duties
Disclosures: Licensees must inform customers (in writing) that their examination/fitting by a hearing aid dealer is not a medical diagnosis or medical care by a physician. regulations.justia.com
For minors: additional protections (physician examination, written authority). For adults, opportunity to waive, but with clear warnings. Conditions such as sudden hearing loss, ear discharge, dizziness, congenital deformity require referral. regulations.justia.com+1
Right to rescind: A buyer may return the hearing aid within 30 days if dissatisfied, with some exceptions. Dealers may still charge reasonable fitting/exam fees. FindLaw Codes
Regulation of Licensure & Discipline
Licensing: Must meet exam requirements (both written and practical), pass tests, etc. Board can recognize equivalent exam from other jurisdiction under reciprocity if standards are similar. West Virginia Code
Display and renewals: License must be posted, renewal fees paid, continuing education required. Renewal period, penalties for late renewal. West Virginia Code+1
Disciplinary actions / prohibited practices: false advertising, using unlicensed persons, mail-order sales (with certain exceptions), fraudulent license conduct. Penalties include fines, license revocation or suspension. West Virginia Code
Legal / Constitutional Issues & Case Law
I searched for specific case law litigating West Virginia Agency 8 rules; there are few reported cases that directly challenge these particular rules. The nature of cases tends to focus more on licensing board procedures, due process, or on related professions (audiology, medical practice). However, some principles and legal background are relevant:
Due Process and Hearing Rights
Entities regulated by licensing boards must have fair notice, opportunity to be heard, rights to appeal. The rules in Agency 8 (Series 8‑02, etc.) ensure that a licensee or applicant can contest board decisions, request hearings, have evidence, etc. Challenges in similar contexts (other licensing boards) show that if these procedural protections are absent, courts may invalidate board action.
Statutory vs. Rule Authority
Cases in WV have held that a board or agency cannot exceed the authority granted by statute. If a rule or regulation under Agency 8 went beyond what the legislature authorized in Chapter 30 Article 26, there would be grounds for challenge. I did not find a reported case yet where a court struck down an Agency 8 rule on that ground, but it's a legal principle.
Rights of Consumers
The clauses giving consumers the right to rescind, for example, must be honored. If a dealer fails to provide proper receipt or fails disclosures, consumer may have cause for complaint or suit.
Criminal Convictions & Character
The rules allow for consideration of prior convictions. Under West Virginia law, licensing boards evaluating criminal history must consider whether the conviction has a rational nexus to the profession/licensing purpose. This is consistent with general WV precedent (in other licensing cases) that past convictions are not automatically disqualifying unless relevant. While I did not locate a case specifically with hearing aid dealers making this challenge, analogous cases (for other professions) support that principle.
Sunset / Transfer of Duties
There has been recent legislative change: the statute provides that the Board of Hearing-Aid Dealers and Fitters is to terminate (sunset) and that the duties of regulation/licensure are to be transferred to the Board of Examiners for Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology. This kind of administrative restructuring sometimes gives rise to legal challenges or clarifications as to whether rules or pending cases will continue under the new authority. West Virginia Code
Potential Case Scenarios / Issues
Although I did not find many specific published appellate cases that, for example, overturned a Board decision under Agency 8, here are typical issues that could give rise to litigation, based on the structure rules and legal principles:
A hearing aid dealer fails to obtain written physician authorization for a minor, despite the minor not having a recent physician exam. A consumer gets harmed (e.g. poor fitting) and sues, alleging violation of §30‑26‑14 and the rules under Agency 8.
A dealer advertises hearing aids via mail‐order unlawfully, and a complaint leads to penalty. Dealer challenges that the statute or rule is vague or exceeds legislative authority.
An applicant with a criminal conviction seeks licensure; board denies. Applicant challenges whether conviction has rational nexus, whether board procedure was fair (due process) under the rules (e.g. Series 8‑05: consideration of prior convictions).
A dispute over the rescission deadline or receipt: dealer refuses to accept return after 30 days, but the buyer claims dealer never issued proper receipt or disclosure. Consumer sues.
Limitations & Important Notes
Licensing boards are often given discretion, but must act consistently with statute and constitutional limits (e.g. cannot impose requirements not authorized by statute).
The rules must be clearly promulgated following the state’s administrative procedures (under WV’s Chapter 29A rules on rulemaking). If a rule was not properly adopted, its enforceability could be challenged.
Changes due to sunset / transfer of board responsibilities could affect interpretation, especially in cases where licensing or disciplinary matters straddle the changeover.
RELATED Blog
0 comments