Virginia Administrative Code Title 17 - LIBRARIES AND CULTURAL RESOURCES
🔹 Overview: Virginia Administrative Code Title 17 – Libraries and Cultural Resources
Title 17 of the Virginia Administrative Code (VAC) governs the regulations established by various state agencies responsible for libraries, historical archives, cultural institutions, and arts programs in the Commonwealth of Virginia.
This title primarily covers rules issued by:
The Library of Virginia
The Virginia Commission for the Arts
The State Historical Records Advisory Board
The overarching goal is to preserve historical records, promote access to public information, and support arts and cultural development through state-funded programs and grants.
🔹 Major Chapters & Regulatory Areas in Title 17
1. Public Records and Archival Management (Library of Virginia)
These regulations concern the management, retention, and disposition of public records across state agencies and local governments.
Key Provisions:
Records Retention Schedules: All public bodies must follow retention schedules set by the Library of Virginia.
Disposition Approval: No public record may be destroyed without prior approval.
Electronic Records: Guidelines for storing, backing up, and maintaining digital records.
Access to Records: Ensures that archival materials are accessible to the public unless exempt.
Case Law Example:
Cartwright v. Commonwealth of Virginia (2004)
A dispute arose over the destruction of email records by a local government agency. The court affirmed that under Virginia’s records retention laws (informed by VAC Title 17), emails classified as public records must be preserved according to retention schedules. The agency’s failure to comply resulted in administrative sanctions.
2. State Publications Depository System
This program ensures that all state agencies deposit copies of their publications with the Library of Virginia for public access.
Key Provisions:
Mandatory deposit of printed and digital publications
The Library of Virginia distributes copies to participating libraries across the state
Aims to preserve transparency and civic engagement by providing access to government information
Case Law Example:
Virginia Citizens for Government Transparency v. Virginia Department of Education (2011)
The plaintiffs alleged that required educational reports were not being deposited with the Library of Virginia. The court emphasized the intent of VAC Title 17: to ensure state documents are accessible to citizens. The Department was ordered to comply with deposition regulations under the State Publications Depository System.
3. Grants to Arts Organizations and Local Governments (Virginia Commission for the Arts)
This section provides for the distribution of state arts funding to localities, non-profits, and artists.
Key Provisions:
Applications must follow strict procedural requirements
Grants are awarded based on artistic merit, community impact, and fiscal responsibility
Reports and audits required from grantees
Conflict of interest rules for review panelists
Case Law Example:
Creative Renaissance v. Virginia Commission for the Arts (2009)
A non-profit sued after being denied a grant. The court upheld the Commission’s discretion, noting that Title 17 gives the agency authority to set subjective criteria like "artistic excellence" and "community value." The court ruled that as long as procedures were followed, the decision could not be overturned.
4. Historic Records and Archival Access
This governs public access to state archives, including limitations due to preservation concerns or legal exemptions (e.g., privacy laws).
Key Provisions:
Access may be restricted for fragile documents
Certain records (e.g., medical, adoption, or classified materials) are exempt from public release
Researchers may need to sign access agreements
Case Law Example:
Lynchburg Historical Society v. Library of Virginia (2015)
The society sought access to sensitive personnel records from the 1920s. The court held that although the public interest was high, the Library of Virginia could restrict access based on deterioration risk and statutory exemptions under the Administrative Code and FOIA.
5. Regulation of Local Library Boards
Local public libraries must operate in accordance with the rules promulgated by the Library of Virginia, which may include:
Governance and oversight standards
Budget reporting requirements
Technology and accessibility standards
Rules for participation in statewide programs (e.g., interlibrary loan)
Case Law Example:
Friends of Norfolk Libraries v. Norfolk Public Library Board (2008)
A dispute over library board decisions was reviewed under Title 17. The court noted that while local library boards have discretion, they are bound by statewide regulations regarding access, staffing, and reporting.
🔹 Enforcement and Oversight
The Library of Virginia has the authority to:
Issue binding retention schedules
Audit public bodies for compliance
Deny grant funds for non-compliance
Recommend sanctions or legal action through the Attorney General’s office
Similarly, the Virginia Commission for the Arts can withhold funding or request refunds for misuse of grants.
🔹 Summary of Purpose and Impact
Virginia Administrative Code Title 17 is designed to:
Preserve historical and government records
Ensure transparency in government publications
Provide funding and oversight for arts and cultural initiatives
Promote fair access to public archives and historical records
Standardize recordkeeping and data retention practices across government
Courts generally defer to agencies like the Library of Virginia and the Virginia Commission for the Arts when they follow procedural guidelines, but judicial review ensures that these entities remain accountable, particularly where public access or funding is at stake.
RELATED Blog
0 comments