Rule of Law
⚖️ Rule of Law – Explained in Detail
✅ 1. Introduction
The Rule of Law is a fundamental principle of constitutional governance. It means that no one is above the law—not the government, not public officials, and not private citizens. It ensures equality before the law, protection of individual rights, and accountability of power.
This concept is central to the Indian Constitution and has been upheld and expanded by the Indian judiciary in numerous landmark cases.
📚 2. Origin of the Concept
The term “Rule of Law” was popularized by A.V. Dicey, a British constitutional theorist, in his work “Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution” (1885).
According to Dicey, Rule of Law comprises three main principles:
Supremacy of Law – No one is above the law.
Equality before Law – Everyone is subject to the same law.
Predominance of Legal Spirit – Rights are secured through courts.
📜 3. Rule of Law in the Indian Constitution
Though the phrase “Rule of Law” is not explicitly used in the Constitution, it is deeply embedded in:
Preamble – Justice, Liberty, and Equality reflect Rule of Law.
Article 14 – Equality before the law and equal protection of laws.
Article 21 – Protection of life and personal liberty through due process.
Article 32 & 226 – Right to constitutional remedies, ensuring legal protection.
The **Supreme Court has declared Rule of Law to be part of the Basic Structure of the Constitution in multiple judgments, meaning it cannot be abrogated even by a constitutional amendment.
📌 4. Core Principles of Rule of Law
| Principle | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Supremacy of Law | Law governs the country, not arbitrary will. |
| Equality Before Law | No person is above the law, all are equal before courts. |
| Accountability of Government | Government officials are accountable under the law. |
| Fair Legal Process | Individuals must be tried fairly and legally. |
| Independent Judiciary | Courts must be free from political influence. |
🧑⚖️ 5. Important Case Laws in India
A. A.K. Gopalan v. State of Madras (1950)
Facts: Gopalan was detained under the Preventive Detention Act.
Issue: Whether his fundamental rights under Article 21 were violated.
Held: Initially, the court took a narrow view, holding that "procedure established by law" meant any law passed by the legislature.
Significance: This judgment was later overruled in Maneka Gandhi’s case, where Rule of Law was better established.
B. Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973)
Doctrine of Basic Structure introduced.
Rule of Law was recognized as part of the basic structure, meaning Parliament cannot violate it even through constitutional amendments.
C. Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978)
Facts: Her passport was impounded without being given a reason.
Issue: Whether this violated Article 21.
Held: The Court expanded the meaning of “procedure established by law” to mean just, fair, and reasonable procedure.
Significance: Strengthened the Rule of Law by ensuring due process is followed.
D. Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975)
The Supreme Court held that free and fair elections are a part of the Rule of Law and the basic structure of the Constitution.
E. I.R. Coelho v. State of Tamil Nadu (2007)
Held that laws inserted into the Ninth Schedule (which were immune from judicial review) can still be reviewed if they violate the basic structure, including Rule of Law.
F. Union of India v. Raghubir Singh (1989)
The Court stated that judicial decisions must follow the law, and judges are not above the law, reinforcing the Rule of Law.
⚖️ 6. Rule of Law vs. Rule by Law
| Rule of Law | Rule by Law |
|---|---|
| Law is supreme and applies equally to all | Law may be used as a tool of power |
| Focuses on fairness, justice, and accountability | Focuses on legality, even if unfair or unjust |
| Integral to democracy | Can exist even in authoritarian regimes |
🛡️ 7. Application in Governance
Prevents arbitrary arrests and detentions
Guarantees fundamental rights
Ensures judicial review of executive and legislative actions
Requires transparency and reasoned decision-making
Protects citizens against misuse of power
📘 8. Summary Table
| Aspect | Details |
|---|---|
| Origin | A.V. Dicey (British legal theorist) |
| Key Elements | Supremacy of law, equality, legal protection |
| Constitutional Basis | Articles 14, 21, 32; Preamble |
| Part of Basic Structure | Yes (as held in Kesavananda Bharati case) |
| Judiciary’s Role | Interprets and enforces Rule of Law through fair trials and review |
| Important Case | Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978) |
✅ 9. Conclusion
The Rule of Law is not just a legal principle but a foundational value in the Indian democratic framework. It ensures that all individuals, including the State, are accountable to the law, and that laws must be just, fair, and reasonable. Through its interpretation of fundamental rights and the basic structure doctrine, the Supreme Court has firmly embedded Rule of Law in Indian constitutional jurisprudence.
RELATED Blog
0 comments